Comments Thread For: Canelo: Those Who Know More About Boxing - Consider Me P4P Best

[ValarMargulis]

LB for LB

Respectfully, Canelo is not #1 to me. But that isn't his fault. The fighters in his weight isn't really worth mentioning. Aside from GGG, I cannot name anyone that would give Canelo fits. Again, that isn't his fault that he's in a weaker division.

[Boxing Scene]

****ing convicted proven cheater and nothing more. You had to cheat to beat a guy you avoided for 2 years and then got a damn gift draw. What a joke.

[Boxing Scene]

Respectfully, Canelo is not #1 to me. But that isn't his fault. The fighters in his weight isn't really worth mentioning. Aside from GGG, I cannot name anyone that would give Canelo fits. Again, that isn't his fault that he's in a weaker division.

Maybe it's the peds? Or the cherry picking? Maybe it's fighting the worst champions? Avoiding GGG for 2 years? The weight games?

[Ochoa780]

Genuine question

Why would you rank Spence so high? Is Porter rank 6 in your list, because that fight was 50/50. Outside of Porter you have a very competitive fight with Brook, ending because of a pre-existing injury, Mike Garcia and Danny Garcia

that’s the entirety of fights worth considering. That isn’t a top 5 P4P resume to me. With Crawford people aren’t sure how good he is as no one has really tested him, so he has that unknown factor (I disagree with him ranked so highly, but can understand). We know Spence’s level, and that is Brook/Porter level

Spence broke kells uninjured orbital bone buddy. And crawford hasnt been tested by anyone cause he hasnt been fought anyone that would be considered a test lol hes fought bums

[lopetego]

P4P#1 Bossnelo speaking facts

Crawford is an unproven, cherrypicking twat who still has to fight a prime, top fighter in his own division

[chepboxingking]

How?

Jermell has proven himself as the kingpin at 154, and was very unfortunate to get that loss... I used to criticise Jermell for being the weaker sibling but he has consistently proven me wrong. He’s doing what great champions should do

Jermall has stalled his career at middleweight, arguably losing to Korobov and scraping fights against D’chenko. He has been there since mid-2017.

Pair with the fact that Middleweight is one of the weakest divisions in the sport, and 154 is arguably the strongest

The difference is night and day

Jermall is undefeated, a 2 div champ, beat J-rock back when he was one of the best prospect, beat a fighter many believe beat GGG in d'chenko. Korobov fight was close, but remember he was preparing to fight someone with a totally different style. Jermell has 3 belts, but its not like he faced any of the other top 154 pounder on PBC roster (Lara, Hurd, jrock).

It's honestly a toss up between the 2, both are great, i just prefer Jermall body of work slightly more than jermell's

[sicko]

Yeah a lot of Boxers and Trainers have him #1 P4P

Compared to a lot of Fans and Boxing Writers and Reporters who seems to go out of their way to NOT make him #1

[batista84]

Jermell over Jamal? I personally think they're both top 10, but I rank Jamal higher

It's a tough pick, because Jermall is my number 7 on P4P just below Usyk and he's beat top opposiiton too, I just think Jermell has a better resume than Jermall.

[batista84]

That list is hilarious. Canelo is the only one who is actually 100% proven. Crawford fighting faded fighters in Khan and Brook. Spence did the same with Brook and only just fought someone decent in Garcia. Doesn't take much to get on your list!

P4P lists are very subjective.

What's yours?

[pepzz]

yup Nelo is number 1!