Miguel Cotto beating Sergio Martinez was NOT a great win

[boliodogs]

Cotto was the pretend middleweight champion. He never fought at 160 like real middleweight champs do. He beat washed up Martinez at a 159 catchweight he demanded. He went on vacation for a year before defended against Geale at a catchweight of 157 when Geale had already been quickly and easily KOed be GGG. Then Cotto defended his title against Canelo at yet another catchweight of 155.

[kidbazooka]

It was a good win but Sergio’s knees were done.

[Citizen Koba]

Yes.

As I said Stephen Edwards constantly praises that win for Cotto in his Daily Bread mailbags.

It's baffling to me, coming from someone who usually offers intelligent boxing commentary.

For sure, Breadman's probably my favourite pundit but just now and then he comes out with something that just leaves you wtf?

I honestly hadn't noticed that one but it doesn't really surprise me, same as when he claimed Sergio ducked GGG... much as I was a Golovkin fan it just made zero sense for Maravilla in any timeframe.