Best heavyweight of all time?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ghost Jab
    Espiran the Great & Noble
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jun 2020
    • 368
    • 168
    • 637
    • 2,465

    #1

    Best heavyweight of all time?

    Currently, I have my top heavyweight all time list looking something like this.

    1. Rocky Marciano (dude never lost and fought the best, only heavyweight that can say that)

    2. Joe Louis (most title defenses, dynamite in both hands you never saw coming)

    3. Gene Tunney (fought in a tough era over 80 times and only lost one fight)

    4. Evander Holyfield (only guy to beat the Baddest Man on the Planet twice. Has some tough losses on his record and fought past his sell-by date, but all this in the hardest of the hard eras of tough HWs. Never quit.)

    5. Iron Mike Tyson (The Baddest Man on the Planet, enough said)

    6. Muhammad Ali (probably deserved to be higher but we didn’t see much of his prime; I think sixth is a fair ranking but think like I said, we never got to see his peak form)

    7. Joe Frazier (Amazing infighter, schooled a prime Muhammad Ali, but ranked below since he lost the series 2-1)

    8. Jack Johnson (pretty much invented the so-called Urban School of Boxing and has a great resume)

    9. Rid**** Bowe (The man was hot and cold, but he beat my guy Holyfield twice. I’ve got to tip my hat to him, and he made a pretty good name for himself in the toughest HW era of all time)

    10. George Foreman (oldest HW champion and showed great resilience. Based only on raw punch power and not on other factors resulting in KO’s, I believe he was the hardest hitter of all time in my humble opinion)

    With all that said, I feel that if Fury can play his cards right and make the right fights before he retires (and win them of course) then he could fall somewhere on the all time top ten heavyweights list, but obviously not at number one since he does already have the one draw. Also he can’t pass Joe Louis in my opinion. Not enough title defenses. If he beats Wilder a third time, beats Joshua twice, and beats Whyte and Usyk and Parker and Ruiz, I could totally see him somewhere on this list.

    Do you think my eyes are open, or do you think IDKSAB?
  • BodyBagz
    The Stuff Of Nightmares
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Apr 2020
    • 29772
    • 6,045
    • 6,437
    • 108,454

    #2
    Rocky....only fought the best !!!!!!!!!!!

    As soon as I recover, I'll look at the other names

    Comment

    • LoadedWraps
      Official NSB POTY 2016
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Nov 2010
      • 24267
      • 1,021
      • 1,468
      • 190,165

      #3
      Originally posted by Ghost Jab
      Currently, I have my top heavyweight all time list looking something like this.

      1. Rocky Marciano (dude never lost and fought the best, only heavyweight that can say that)

      2. Joe Louis (most title defenses, dynamite in both hands you never saw coming)

      3. Gene Tunney (fought in a tough era over 80 times and only lost one fight)

      4. Evander Holyfield (only guy to beat the Baddest Man on the Planet twice. Has some tough losses on his record and fought past his sell-by date, but all this in the hardest of the hard eras of tough HWs. Never quit.)

      5. Iron Mike Tyson (The Baddest Man on the Planet, enough said)

      6. Muhammad Ali (probably deserved to be higher but we didn’t see much of his prime; I think sixth is a fair ranking but think like I said, we never got to see his peak form)

      7. Joe Frazier (Amazing infighter, schooled a prime Muhammad Ali, but ranked below since he lost the series 2-1)

      8. Jack Johnson (pretty much invented the so-called Urban School of Boxing and has a great resume)

      9. Rid**** Bowe (The man was hot and cold, but he beat my guy Holyfield twice. I’ve got to tip my hat to him, and he made a pretty good name for himself in the toughest HW era of all time)

      10. George Foreman (oldest HW champion and showed great resilience. Based only on raw punch power and not on other factors resulting in KO’s, I believe he was the hardest hitter of all time in my humble opinion)

      With all that said, I feel that if Fury can play his cards right and make the right fights before he retires (and win them of course) then he could fall somewhere on the all time top ten heavyweights list, but obviously not at number one since he does already have the one draw. Also he can’t pass Joe Louis in my opinion. Not enough title defenses. If he beats Wilder a third time, beats Joshua twice, and beats Whyte and Usyk and Parker and Ruiz, I could totally see him somewhere on this list.

      Do you think my eyes are open, or do you think IDKSAB?
      I'd put Fury in front of Marciano, otherwise good list.

      Comment

      • deathofaclown
        Undisputed Champion
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Apr 2015
        • 16322
        • 3,919
        • 50
        • 98,604

        #4
        Fury is the best in the sense none of them would beat him but many had a greater career so far

        Comment

        • BodyBagz
          The Stuff Of Nightmares
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Apr 2020
          • 29772
          • 6,045
          • 6,437
          • 108,454

          #5
          I take it resumes don't matter

          Comment

          • TheMyspaceDayz
            Banned
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Dec 2019
            • 5837
            • 900
            • 623
            • 189,135

            #6
            Muhammad Ali isn’t just the best heavyweight of all time, I’d venture to say he’s the best fighter of all time.

            Comment

            • LoadedWraps
              Official NSB POTY 2016
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Nov 2010
              • 24267
              • 1,021
              • 1,468
              • 190,165

              #7
              Originally posted by TheMyspaceDayz
              Muhammad Ali isn’t just the best heavyweight of all time, I’d venture to say he’s the best fighter of all time.
              Fury would make that man quit.

              Comment

              • BodyBagz
                The Stuff Of Nightmares
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Apr 2020
                • 29772
                • 6,045
                • 6,437
                • 108,454

                #8
                Name recognition and fan hype > Honesty

                Comment

                • Roadblock
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • May 2006
                  • 14031
                  • 3,535
                  • 428
                  • 108,713

                  #9
                  Ali, in his prime non could touch him, and he went on and proved he has no quit at all and one of the greatest chins ever, how the fck can they beat a guy that moves like a LW and is as tough as teak unbreakable.

                  Cassius Clay was the best HW we have seen so far.

                  Comment

                  • aboutfkntime
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Feb 2015
                    • 47370
                    • 1,631
                    • 3,563
                    • 391,308

                    #10
                    1) Ali

                    2) Louis

                    3) the others, in no particular order...

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP