Is Carl Froch a HOF'er?

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

bro, that is NOT the same thing... not even close

As I just said my concept of greatness does not purely relate to talent.

Now stop ducking the question:

Provide an example of the fighters in the HOF who are not great???

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

nah, the HOF is full of fighters who are not genuine greats

but all of the greats will obviously be inducted

Froch is a HOF'er for sure

the greats are very special, in a class of their own

Who are these fighters?????

You’ve failed to name one!

[aboutfkntime]

As I just said my concept of greatness does not purely relate to talent.

Now stop ducking the question:

Provide an example of the fighters in the HOF who are not great???

you already did that

dude, Gatti is in the HOF for his contribution to boxing

you were talking shlt when you provided 2x completely different criteria for the HOF

the HOF is for GREAT fighters IMO

The HOF is about a contribution to the sport.

" contributing ", and being great... are NOT the same thing... so which one is it?

[aboutfkntime]

Who are these fighters?????

You’ve failed to name one!

Rid**** Bowe is not a genuinely great fighter imho... neither is Gatti... neither is McGuigan

answer my question dude...

you gave 2x different criteria for greatness... which is absurd

obviously, both of your criteria cannot be correct

which one is it... ?

the HOF is for GREAT fighters IMO

The HOF is about a contribution to the sport.

[aboutfkntime]

As I just said my concept of greatness does not purely relate to talent.

Now stop ducking the question:

Provide an example of the fighters in the HOF who are not great???

" your concept "... ?

#opinionsarelikea55holes,everyonehasone

you need to remove one of these criteria... which one is it... ?

the HOF is for GREAT fighters IMO

The HOF is about a contribution to the sport.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Rid**** Bowe is not a genuinely great fighter imho... neither is Gatti... neither is McGuigan

answer my question dude...

you gace 2x different criteria for greatness... which is absurd

obviously, both of your criteria cannot be correct

which one is it... ?

It’s a wider concept, it’s a combination of both. You do realise that words can have more than one definition... it’s seriously not that complicated. Different fighters are great for different reasons.

Bowe beat a prime Holyfield twice. Was that not a great win?

McGuigan possibly, but beat a great fighter in Pedroza. Was that not a great win?

Who did Froch beat that was better? What makes you consider him a HOF fighter when he doesn’t have a great win?

[aboutfkntime]

destroying Bute... wars with good/superb fighters like Kessler/Groves... and generally terrorizing super-middleweight for five years... was a outstanding contribution to boxing imho

#bigtimeoverachiever

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

" your concept "... ?

#opinionsarelikea55holes,everyonehasone

you need to remove one of these criteria... which one is it... ?

Read my other post. Certain words have more than one meaning. You’re either ignorant or ****** if you can’t grasp that.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

destroying Bute... wars with good/superb fighters like Kessler/Groves... and generally terrorizing super-middleweight for five years... was a outstanding contribution to boxing imho

#bigtimeoverachiever

So beating a B level guy in Bute and losing to a prime Kessler.

Got ya.😂

[aboutfkntime]

It’s a wider concept, it’s a combination of both. You do realise that words can have more than one definition... it’s seriously not that complicated. Different fighters are great for different reasons.

Bowe beat a prime Holyfield twice. Was that not a great win?

McGuigan possibly, but beat a great fighter in Pedroza. Was that not a great win?

Who did Froch beat that was better? What makes you consider him a HOF fighter when he doesn’t have a great win?

no, it is not... you have already proved yourself wrong

the HOF is for... contributions to the sport

ATG... is for greatness

Bowe/McGuigan/Gatti were inducted into the HOF for contributions to the sport

Froch is only a HOF'er lol

and what an outstanding contribution he made

#overachiever

you should be up to speed now bro... unless you are one of them