Was Castillo robbed of a victory over Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

[PATO 1]

floyd broke 2 ****in ribs and a hand in that fight an still beat JLC

[Rane-Ex54]

No excuses. What you guys should do is get a few friends that rarely watch boxing, shut off the sound, and have them score it or ask them who they think won.

Personally, I do wish Castillo was given the victory. I think he edged it out. Or maybe I just hate hearing mayweather always say, I'm undefeated, and no one will defeat me and they will never figure out how to beat my style. Let it be known. Castillo exposed how to beat his style.

But whats done is done, and mayweather won the fight according to the judges, so we all have to deal & see if someone else can beat him.

[cortdawg25]

Floyd lost the 1st fight, blahblahblah, Still nobody has uploaded the fight and dont upload certain rounds, someone upload this whole fight so we can rewind and pause and see if punches were really landed like they say it was, upload the fight so we can revisit and see if it was a robbery. Cause I remeber Floyd going backwards but countering Castillo with nice flush shots, he easily took about 5 of the early rounds. Castillo came on around the 6th in desperation but still lost atleast 2 rounds in the last 6. He may have even lost the 12th as well as the 11th. So someone uplaod the fight!!!

[Boxing Analyst]

everyone knows Castillo won on the first fight. Whats the point on this debate? nothing!

[GunStar]

Now if anybody watched the three rounds posted at you tube, Harold Lederman had Castillo up by three points after the 11th, even Larry Merchant, who always scores it wrong, had Castillo up by a point, and in my eyes, Castillo won the last round. Floyd kept rabbit punching or hitting Castillo's ears. He kept holding on to Castillo's arm cuz he knew he was going to get hit hard and didn't want it to happen. At the bell of the last round, Floyd hit Castillo with like four or five punches, just at or even after the bell. He's a punk and Castillo was robbed.

Thanks for telling everyone that you've never seen the fight, you judge the fight by 3 biased rounds from the youtube video.

Also let me explain to you something about humanbox, it's done by humans and 99% of the tme is wrong, if you are going to judge a fight by humanbox, please don't ever watch a fight again.

Fact is many PBF haters and Mexicans on this board has many alt accounts, so the vote count from this site doesn't meant **** and we've had this poll like 10 different times already here.

All 3 judges had PBF by 4 or more points, most of the press had this fight for PBF.

Give it a rest already PBF beat Castillo twice fair and square, not like Castillo against Johnston who got 2 gift wins himself.

[GunStar]

everyone knows Castillo won on the first fight. Whats the point on this debate? nothing!

Only Mexicans, Floyd haters, Blind folks, brain washed people, people that never seen the fight, Hatton fans, some Pac fans because of P4P status etc.....

[JoartCC2]

Castillo won the first fight clearly.

Only those hard-core PBF fans say PBF won it. Plain and basic common sense. PBF basically did nothing in that fight but ran all night. Castillo hit him with a lot of good shots, and all PBF did was run, run and run some more.

This is the reason why PBF is ducking Margarito, because he knows in himself he lost that first fight and he doesn't want to face fighters who doesn't play it pretty on his face.

[Hitman18]

Thanks for telling everyone that you've never seen the fight,

Also let me explain to you something about humanbox, it's done by humans and 99% of the tme is wrong, if you are going to judge a fight by humanbox, please don't ever watch a fight again.

First of all, I have seen the fight, tens of twentys of times, I have it downloaded, and if you read the post I posted before I said I couldn't upload the whole fight, but that I did find three rounds from youtube.
Secondly, if you watch boxing, Lederman almost always says, "by compubox number, blah has landed blah punches......etc....."
Idiot

[GunStar]

First of all, I have seen the fight, tens of twentys of times, I have it downloaded, and if you read the post I posted before I said I couldn't upload the whole fight, but that I did find three rounds from youtube.
Secondly, if you watch boxing, Lederman almost always says, "by compubox number, blah has landed blah punches......etc....."
Idiot

Eat some burritos & STFU you ******!

[GunStar]

Castillo won the first fight clearly.

Only those hard-core PBF fans say PBF won it. Plain and basic common sense. PBF basically did nothing in that fight but ran all night. Castillo hit him with a lot of good shots, and all PBF did was run, run and run some more.

This is the reason why PBF is ducking Margarito, because he knows in himself he lost that first fight and he doesn't want to face fighters who doesn't play it pretty on his face.

Who's alt are you??