Whats's more Impressive? Oscar vs Loma

[Murcielago]

Whats's more impressive.

Oscar de la Hoya becoming a 3 division world champion in 22 fights by 23 years old, 4th year as a pro, in 1996, beating -

1. Jimmi Bredahl (16-0) in his 12th fight for the WBO Super Featherweight title at 21 years old in 1994.
   
2. Jorge Paez (53-6-4) in his 14th fight for the vacant WBO Lightweight title at 21 years old. in 1994.
   
3. Julio Cesar Chavez (96-1-1) in his 22nd fight for the WBC Super Lightweight title at 23 years old in 1996.

or


Vasiliy Lomachenko becoming a 3 division world champion in 12 fights by 31 years old, 5th year as a pro, in 2018, beating -

1. Gary Russell Jr (24-0) in his 3rd fight in 2014 for the vacant WBO Featherweight Title at 26 years old.
   
2. Roman Martinez (29-2-3) in his 7th fight for the WBO Super Featherweight Title
   
3. Jorge Linares (44-3-0) in his 12th fight for the WBA Super Lightweight Title at 31 years old.

[Larry the boss]

Oscar, he was younger and less experienced...

[jmrf4435]

12 FIGHTS IS MORE IMPRESSIVE.

plus I favor lomas style. Loma is so fun to watch, the angles and such

[bballchump11]

Lomachenko's records are kinda overrated to me. He turned pro at 25 with close to 400 amateur fights and 6 fights in the WSB where he got paid and had no head guard.

When people say a fighter did something within X number of fights, it implies they were inexperienced or green. Lomachenko was a grown man with plenty of experience. It's not like he's going to retire with over 30 fights.

[MulaKO]

Oscar all the way

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

12 FIGHTS IS MORE IMPRESSIVE.

plus I favor lomas style. Loma is so fun to watch, the angles and such

Yeah Loma’s achievement being far more unique is what swung my vote.

[GhostofDempsey]

Lomachenko's records are kinda overrated to me. He turned pro at 25 with close to 400 amateur fights and 6 fights in the WSB where he got paid and had no head guard.

When people say a fighter did something within X number of fights, it implies they were inexperienced or green. Lomachenko was a grown man with plenty of experience. It's not like he's going to retire with over 30 fights.

Oscar had 228 amateur fights and an Olympic gold medal. It’s not as though he turned pro on a learning curve.

[GhostofDempsey]

Based on on the three fight comparison I would rank Loma higher. But, Oscar was a 6 division champion, something Loma will never come close to.

[Real King Kong]

Oscar had 228 amateur fights and an Olympic gold medal. It’s not as though he turned pro on a learning curve.

Oscar, he was younger and less experienced...

Oscar had plenty of amateur experience and more pro experience.

[bballchump11]

Oscar had 228 amateur fights and an Olympic gold medal. It’s not as though he turned pro on a learning curve.

228 is a lot of amateur fights, but he turned pro at 19 years old. Lomachenko winning a title in his 3rd fight is incredible, but once he had about 6 fights, he was already a seasoned pro and 27 years old. All of those "he accomplished this in ___ fights" records became less meaningful to me.

Oscar won a title in his 3rd weight class in his 22nd fight. Lomachenko will be past his prime by the time his 22nd fight comes.