Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Pound for Pound Update: November 2019

[factsarenice]

The list is either click bait or a paid advertisement that makes me question the integrity of the writer.

[Pantera_]

Great list. I have to give Inoue props for putting the Bantomweights on the map in a huge way! Him vs Pantera Nery has to happen!

[Pantera_]

The only thing I disagree with is Golovkin and Spence still being on there. Golovkin lost the rematch against Canelo in a close fight and he got an absolute gift against D-Chenko. And Spence is a nice guy and all but his resume is lacking and I've just about had enough with this "eye test" crap.

[NachoMan]

Seriously, Cliff, GGG simply cannot be on this list anymore.

[aboutfkntime]

Terrence, Canelo, and Loma are #1-#3.

Inoue is #3/4.

I'm fine with the rest of the lost except GGG. He's off the list. You cant have it both ways saying:

"Ignore the official scores - GGG beat Canelo. Twice!" Then say..."Official scores have GGG beating Dervenchenko...". Everyine except fanboys know damn well Dervenchenko won that fight...

And Josh Taylor is definitely #6-#8 imho.

Why is Spence still rated so highly? His best accomplishment was not killing someone during a DUI...

P4P is subjective... and highly over-rated imo...

Inoue leapfrogged Lomachenko, Crawford, and Canelo... after being exposed a little, by an old Donaire who dropped TWO divisions in the last year-or-so? ...

I have him a solid #4

Usyk, I love the guy... excellent fighter, and excellent guy... but he is one fight away from possibly being removed from the list entirely

Usyk beat 2x unproven guys, and thats it... I still remember what happened in the Bellew fight, Usyk did not look like a P4P fighter at all

not sure whats up there... I wish him all the best, but not sure how successful he will be at heavyweight

and Golovkin still on the list, after losing to Canelo and probably losing to Derevyanchenko... ?

I think there will be some " adjustments " over the next 12 months

I have the top 4...
Crawford/Lomachenko... #1 and #2, no particular order
Canelo
Inoue

I still have Canelo/Inoue one top win away from earning the top spot

Crawford needs to do something

because of his inactivity against anyone worth a damn, in 12 months I can see...
1) Canelo
2) Lomachenko
3) Inoue
4) Crawford

[ShoulderRoll]

Inoue struggled a bit with an old Donaire who cut weight to fight at bantam.

I can't put him at #1 after that performance. He has to beat Nery then we'll talk.

Canelo deserves the top spot in my opinion. He proved himself the best at middleweight and as one of the best at light heavyweight as well.

[djbiancafrost]

Red k sent.

Article should have been made after Leo Santa Cruz wins his 4th division title next week

A WBA Super 130 belt that was supposed to be for ANDREW CANCIO. Cancio should be in line for that belt (well you know how the history of Machado's original belt was taken away by Gervonta).

[1hourRun]

Josh Taylor cracks the top ten.

I think I'm going to be SICK! P4P?! HOW?! Did you guys see Viktor Postol, Ivan Baranchyk and Regis Prograis whooping the 'Tart-Tomato'? No way this bum has the skills to jump weight divisions and be champion at 147! That's what P4P do!

Josh Taylor is OVERRATED!!!

[patron]

Interesting list. Always surprises me when a boxer out of no where comes to claim the #1 spot.

[1hourRun]

This is worse than I thought, I just seen Bumchenko ahead of Terence Crawford. Would Luke Campbell ever done this to Terence Crawford?! WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON?!