Who wins: the Pacquiao that beat Margarito vs the Canelo that lost to Mayweather?

[Roadblock]

Sounds like your being sarcastic.
You sound like thurman did before losing to pac.
But history shows Pac beats common opponents more dominant or more times

You never heard of JMM I take it, or that Floyd fought better versions of ALL the other common opponents.

[pasawayako]

A 152 canelo vs the dela hoya that pac fought would haven been an even match up..

[dibzvincent143]

One of the judges scored Mayweather-Canelo a draw and Pacquiao was on the side of bad calls against Bradley and Horn, while Canelo always lands on the good side of close fights. I wonder if Pacquiao would've gotten a decision in that match up even if he deserved it.

Against bradley and horn, pac was already on the downside.. we talkin a premargarito version.. i believed that was the last part of pacquiao’s absolute prime..

I think he’d bust that 152 version of canelo..

[South Champion]

Against bradley and horn, pac was already on the downside.. we talkin a premargarito version.. i believed that was the last part of pacquiao’s absolute prime..

I think he’d bust that 152 version of canelo..

I agree that this prime version of Pacquiao beats 152 Canelo. Although, it's a little difficult to imagine Canelo being beat down by an opponent so short and light.

[Marchegiano]

I have to disagree

1st, Margarito was at his ''best'' at WW.
2nd, He gave life above WW a shot and was sent back down.
3rd, He had a rough time with Clottey

Margarito vs Angulo would have been entertaining

Oh, I'm not willing to go to bat for that one my man. I just think the styles would have made for an explosive fight, not close.

Maybe a better way to say it is prime Marg woulda made Canelo look real good?

Anyway, not worth arguing over, if you don't reckon so I respect that, no bigs.

[Curtis Harper]

Oh, I'm not willing to go to bat for that one my man. I just think the styles would have made for an explosive fight, not close.

Maybe a better way to say it is prime Marg woulda made Canelo look real good?

Anyway, not worth arguing over, if you don't reckon so I respect that, no bigs.

Not arguing....just laughing out loud (in the realist sense). The commentators of the Clottey fight nailed Margarito perfectly (kinda) -
''He's (Margarito) not very talented but he's fun to watch !''

Watching a slow clumsy oaf plod forward swinging telegraphed punches tends to get boring after a while.

For me at least

[tjones1989]

Everybody talking about that midget pacquiao and how he's going to whoop on canelo. Let's be real here. Canelo would slam on midget pacquiao, it does not matter what pacquiao does man!

[Roadblock]

A 152 canelo vs the dela hoya that pac fought would haven been an even match up..

The 145lb Oscar that Manny beat would have been stopped by any top 10 WW, they had to find a LW in Steve Forbes to give Oscar a win at 150, he nearly lost lol and Manny beat a 5lb lighter again Oscar , joke fight.

[pasawayako]

The 145lb Oscar that Manny beat would have been stopped by any top 10 WW, they had to find a LW in Steve Forbes to give Oscar a win at 150, he nearly lost lol and Manny beat a 5lb lighter again Oscar , joke fight.

a 152 canelo would have beaten by any top 20 jr. middleweigjt with ease. A 147lbs oscar would probably annihilated a 152lbs canelo....

[Curtis Harper]

If I had to say something positive about Pac -
He has an appealing style.

The negatives -
HIS FANS
His ''no 100 % random testing'' stance and the plethora of excuses he used.

''Some'' Pac fans can be compared to seeing a good movie only for it to be ruined by low lifes talking.