Better resume at 154 - Charlo or Munguia?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Boxing_1013
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Feb 2019
    • 6845
    • 184
    • 256
    • 157,917

    #1

    Better resume at 154 - Charlo or Munguia?

    Vote, discuss...I can't see how anyone can say Munguia's resume at 154 is even in the same realm as Charlo's right now personally.

    This is a thread in response to another poster who keeps insisting that boxrec's rating system is seemingly perfect to him...he keeps defending it at every turn...I pointed out that Munguia being ranked 1 at 154 and Jermell being ranked 9 at 154, is evidence that their rating system (while overall good imo) can be seriously flawed.

    I like boxrec for their resources and think their rating system is pretty good...but when they have Munguia 1 at 154...Charlo 9 at 154...Benevidez 8 at 168, Plant 9 at 168, Danny Garcia like 12 in pfp...Fury 5 at HW, and Usyk 4 at HW ahead of him...I mean some of those are bad ratings, and some are so bad that they basically make the ratings there lose all credibility, unfortunately.
    12
    Charlo
    83.33%
    10
    Munguia
    16.67%
    2
  • ShaneMosleySr
    Banned
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Mar 2019
    • 10325
    • 1,049
    • 903
    • 276,311

    #2
    Anyone who votes for Munguia should be shot.

    Comment

    • Boxing_1013
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Feb 2019
      • 6845
      • 184
      • 256
      • 157,917

      #3
      Originally posted by ShaneMosleySr
      Anyone who votes for Munguia should be shot.
      Yeah...I guess for some when having a debate, you can kind of twist yourself in knots to try and 'win' the debate and defend your original point...couldn't believe he wouldn't just admit boxrec is way off on that one

      Comment

      • boliodogs
        Undisputed Champion
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2008
        • 33358
        • 824
        • 1,782
        • 309,589

        #4
        On paper Munguia has the better resume of course because he has a perfect record. If you watch their fights it's easy to se Jermell is the better fighter so I voted for him.

        Comment

        • Blue54
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Jun 2017
          • 1220
          • 61
          • 8
          • 65,942

          #5
          Smith and Ali are Mugani only decent wins while Jermell has 1st rd Ko over Lubin! Wins over Trout, Martyrosin, Hatley.

          Comment

          • Boxing_1013
            Undisputed Champion
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Feb 2019
            • 6845
            • 184
            • 256
            • 157,917

            #6
            Originally posted by boliodogs
            On paper Munguia has the better resume of course because he has a perfect record. If you watch their fights it's easy to se Jermell is the better fighter so I voted for him.
            I would say Jermell's resume is way superior to Munguia's right now too.

            Originally posted by Blue54
            Smith and Ali are Mugani only decent wins while Jermell has 1st rd Ko over Lubin! Wins over Trout, Martyrosin, Hatley.
            Even if you give credit for Hogan for Munguia...he literally has nothing else other than those 3.

            Charlo has Lubin, Trout, Vanes...Rosado, and even Alcine and Jackson and Hatley if you want to go that far...Charlo's resume overall is way past Jamie's right now.

            Comment

            • MASTER OF you
              Interim Champion
              Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
              • Nov 2015
              • 533
              • 19
              • 16
              • 13,056

              #7
              charlo lost to a bum. he's a hype job who has been exposed!

              Comment

              • JakeTheBoxer
                undisputed champion
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Dec 2014
                • 21191
                • 4,641
                • 2,802
                • 123,960

                #8
                Munguia is a kid on learning season, he shouldn`t even have a belt.

                Comment

                Working...
                TOP