BoxingScene Champions

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Marchegiano
    Banned
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Aug 2010
    • 12209
    • 1,790
    • 2,307
    • 165,288

    #1

    BoxingScene Champions

    The polls have been open for 24 hours now. I won't close them, I'll just replace them when titles exchange. So, there's still time to change the results.

    To build suspense, I'll go in reverse order.




    BoxingScene Champions:

    Minimumweight: Wanheng Menayothin 80%

    Light Flyweight: Ken Shiro 87.5%

    Flyweight: Kosei Tanaka 87.5%

    Super Flyweight: Juan F. Estrada 91.67%

    Bantamweight: Naoya Inoue 92%

    Super Bantamweight: Emanuel Navarrete 52.38%

    Featherweight: Leo Santa Cruz 41.67%

    Super Featherweight: Miguel Berchelt 73.91%

    Lightweight: Vasyl Lomachenko 97.50%

    Super Lightweight: Jose Ramirez 63.33%

    Welterweight: Errol Spence Jr. 51.02%

    Super Welterweight: Julian Williams 80%

    Middleweight: Canelo Alvarez 55.36%

    Super Middleweight: Callum Smith 75.68%

    Light Heavyweight: Artur Beterbiev 74.51%

    Cruiserweight: Mairis Briedis 63.64%

    Heavyweight: Tyson Fury 38.03%

    Pound for Pound: Vasyl Lomachenko 58.33%


    ----------------------------------------------------

    Least disputed champion in boxing: Lightweight: Vasyl Lomachenko 97.50%


    Most disputed champion in boxing: Heavyweight: Tyson Fury 38.03%


    Least interesting weight division in boxing: Light Flyweight & Flyweight only got 8 votes each.

    Most interesting weight division in boxing: Heavyweight with 72 votes.


    Congratulations to the champions! Thanks for voting!


    ----------------------------------------------------------

    It'll update results when there's a change. I don't think Haney's promotion warrants asking the Loma question again.


    The polls are stickied, but, here's a link anyway:
    Last edited by Marchegiano; 10-25-2019, 12:37 PM.
  • ShaneMosleySr
    Banned
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Mar 2019
    • 10325
    • 1,049
    • 903
    • 276,311

    #2
    There should be a rule where someone has to get a certain percentage of the vote to be named champion.

    For example, there clearly isn’t a champion at heavyweight since none of us agree.

    You should also include Guillermo Rigodeaux in the 122 pound division since he never lost a fight at that weight, is the current lineal champion and the WBA only stripped him for moving up to fight Lomachenko which is insane.

    Comment

    • Marchegiano
      Banned
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Aug 2010
      • 12209
      • 1,790
      • 2,307
      • 165,288

      #3
      Originally posted by ShaneMosleySr
      There should be a rule where someone has to get a certain percentage of the vote to be named champion.

      For example, there clearly isn’t a champion at heavyweight since none of us agree.

      You should also include Guillermo Rigodeaux in the 122 pound division since he never lost a fight at that weight, is the current lineal champion and the WBA only stripped him for moving up to fight Lomachenko which is insane.
      I thought about that for just a second myself but reckon'd folks would suggest I did that to save Wilder the embarrassment as my sig gives away my fandom.


      Before I make more champions polls I'm going to make polls on rules and judgements. For example, loads asked for vacancy. I think vacancy just makes it more convoluted. I was trying to have official BS picks for men who are champions. Being able to declare no champion is a bit of an affront to the idea, but, who am I to tell y'all what's right to do?

      So, by the community for the community is how I'll be running this.

      Let yer objections be heard, I'll poll the community and make a thread with results.

      Comment

      • Marchegiano
        Banned
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Aug 2010
        • 12209
        • 1,790
        • 2,307
        • 165,288

        #4
        BoxingScene Champions:

        Minimumweight: Wanheng Menayothin 80% - WBC

        Light Flyweight: Ken Shiro 87.5% - WBC

        Flyweight: Kosei Tanaka 87.5% - WBO

        Super Flyweight: Juan F. Estrada 91.67% - WBC

        Bantamweight: Naoya Inoue 92% - WBA IBF

        Super Bantamweight: Emanuel Navarrete 52.38% - WBO

        Featherweight: Leo Santa Cruz 41.67% - WBA

        Super Featherweight: Miguel Berchelt 73.91% - WBC

        Lightweight: Vasyl Lomachenko 97.50% - WBA WBC WBO

        Super Lightweight: Jose Ramirez 63.33% - WBC WBO

        Welterweight: Errol Spence Jr. 51.02% - WBC IBF

        Super Welterweight: Julian Williams 80% - WBA IBF

        Middleweight: Canelo Alvarez 55.36% - WBC WBA

        Super Middleweight: Callum Smith 75.68% - WBA

        Light Heavyweight: Artur Beterbiev 74.51% - WBC IBF

        Cruiserweight: Mairis Briedis 63.64% - WBO

        Heavyweight: Tyson Fury 38.03% - None




        WBC = 9

        WBA = 6

        WBO = 5

        IBF = 4


        The WBC champions seem to be BoxingScene's favorite champions. Does this bring any legitimacy to the WBC's prestigious claim?

        Comment

        • Rusty Tromboni
          Banned
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Dec 2018
          • 4353
          • 70
          • 103
          • 116,487

          #5
          Originally posted by ShaneMosleySr

          For example, there clearly isn’t a champion at heavyweight since none of us agree.
          Shows how ****** people here are. Fury's con****uously the best in that weight class. And not just at present, ever.

          I've never seen "fans" of a sport/subject so illiterate on the topic.

          "I like dat guy cuz he looks like my friend from choich"

          "I like dat fighter cuz he orders da same fing I do from Waffle House"

          "He musta won dat fight. He wear da freshest kick. Urr Furce Wunnz!"

          A conversation with an average Boxing "fan" quickly starts to feel like an advertisement for Planned Parenthood.

          Comment

          • Marchegiano
            Banned
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Aug 2010
            • 12209
            • 1,790
            • 2,307
            • 165,288

            #6
            Originally posted by Rusty Tromboni
            Shows how ****** people here are. Fury's con****uously the best in that weight class. And not just at present, ever.

            I've never seen "fans" of a sport/subject so illiterate on the topic.

            "I like dat guy cuz he looks like my friend from choich"

            "I like dat fighter cuz he orders da same fing I do from Waffle House"

            "He musta won dat fight. He wear da freshest kick. Urr Furce Wunnz!"

            A conversation with an average Boxing "fan" quickly starts to feel like an advertisement for Planned Parenthood.
            Talk about anything boxing related here. Where the boxing discussion is always Non Stop!

            Comment

            • Rusty Tromboni
              Banned
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Dec 2018
              • 4353
              • 70
              • 103
              • 116,487

              #7
              Yup.

              It's like the transcript from a conversation held at a Down Syndrome Convention.


              If you know Boxing you know Fury runs away with it.

              Here's a realistic top 10 for the current Heavyweight Division:

              1-9) Fury
              10) Someone who doesn't know who his dad really is.

              The footage is readily available. This isn't hard. If you don't get it, stick to the NBA.

              Comment

              Working...
              TOP