Which one would you rather see?

**amagnin** · 07-28-2006, 03:50 PM

Originally posted by meldubb

If you had to pick one and one only to actually happened what would it be? Floyd vs De La Hoya or Floyd vs Mosley?

At what weight? If I had to see a fight at 154 I would choose DLH because he is more comfortable there. If it was Shane I would choose 147 for the same reason. If these are my choices then I choose Shane because I think he has a better chance of beating Floyd. But if I wanted to see a masterful performance then I would choose DLH because Floyd will never look better than fighting against his dad (DLH's trainer). Both Mosley and DLH are a little past their prime so I would rather see Floyd take on guys closer to his age that are considered elite. Margarito, Cotto, Hatton etc.

**Derranged_** · 07-28-2006, 03:50 PM

To be honest, right now I would love to see Hatton and Baldomir go at it. I think that their styles match up in such a way that the fight would be a "war of attrition" and would come down to which man wants it the most.

Plus, I think it'd be a non-ppv matter.

**jai mari078** · 07-28-2006, 04:00 PM

Originally posted by amagnin

At what weight? If I had to see a fight at 154 I would choose DLH because he is more comfortable there. If it was Shane I would choose 147 for the same reason. If these are my choices then I choose Shane because I think he has a better chance of beating Floyd. But if I wanted to see a masterful performance then I would choose DLH because Floyd will never look better than fighting against his dad (DLH's trainer). Both Mosley and DLH are a little past their prime so I would rather see Floyd take on guys closer to his age that are considered elite. Margarito, Cotto, Hatton etc.

I would rather see De La Hoya. When this fight happens,it will be at 154lbs. Oscar has already said there will be no catch weight if Floyd wants to fight him. Floyd is already a small welter, and at jr.middle I think Oscar has achance of beating him. I would like to see Mosley at welter, and i think this would be a good fight. I don't think that Floyd could hurt or put either one of them down, he would have to box,box,box. I think people are wrong if they think that Oscar or Shane wouldn't have a chance against Floyd. I don't think it is out of the question that one or both of them could win this fight.

**amagnin** · 07-28-2006, 04:04 PM

Originally posted by jai mari078

I would rather see De La Hoya. When this fight happens,it will be at 154lbs. Oscar has already said there will be no catch weight if Floyd wants to fight him. Floyd is already a small welter, and at jr.middle I think Oscar has achance of beating him. I would like to see Mosley at welter, and i think this would be a good fight. I don't think that Floyd could hurt or put either one of them down, he would have to box,box,box. I think people are wrong if they think that Oscar or Shane wouldn't have a chance against Floyd. I don't think it is out of the question that one or both of them could win this fight.

I am in total agreement with your analysis and I heard the same thing out of the DLH camp about weight. The reason I think Shane and Floyd would be a better fight is that I like Floyd at 147 better than 154. At 147 both have good speed and if Shane is throwing the combinations it has the makings of an exciting fight. I think Floyd does box, box, box against DLH and wins a decision. It won't be easy but if he can avoid the big punch I don't think he will have a problem out-slicking Oscar at this point in Oscar's career.

**Kid Achilles** · 07-28-2006, 04:04 PM

I don't want to see Floyd beat up on either of these guys who are both passed their primes. I want to see him fight Margarito or Hatton, someone who might actually pose a threat to him.

I apologize, maybe it's wrong of me to want to live in the present and not five years ago when Shane Mosley was one of the best fighters in the world. LOL!

Let's see Floyd fight someone young and dangerous, not old and injured.

**AREALFIGHTER** · 07-28-2006, 04:05 PM

Floyd vs Oscar. Oscar has already lost to mosely twice and I would rather see him in with someone new.

**TheGreat1** · 07-28-2006, 04:08 PM

PBF vs. De la Hola, only because we have seen Mosely dominated before, no one has able been able to do that to DHL. (except for Tito in the last 5 rounds)

**-EX-** · 07-28-2006, 04:08 PM

I don't think it would be smart for Floyd to go up to 154 at all. At 147 I think he can beat Oscar. I'd like to see Mayweather and Mosley at 147. Both have great handspeed could be a good fight.

**meldubb** · 07-28-2006, 04:08 PM

you actually think hatton or margarito can pose a threat to floyd? ha ha ha thats funny!

Which one would you rather see?