Your P4P Top 5

[elfag]

No offense to the TS but I just can't see how anyone would put Rigo (who has done NOTHING of significance after the Donaire win and then quitting in a fight that mattered most) and Jacobs (who lost 2 of his biggest fights) as a P4P Top 5 but NOT Loma and Canelo, the two guys that beat them, it's just not possible and it makes no sense...

OP's list makes perfect sense once you see him. OP is comrade ****** on the far right.

[Rusty Tromboni]

1) Loma
2) Fury
3) Usyk
4) Canelo
5) Golovkin


I had Golovkin winning both fights handedly. But his performance against the Ukrainian finally sinks him below canelo, whom he's beaten.

[Rusty Tromboni]

Who do you consider to be the P4P top 5 at the moment and why? I see it like this...

1: Crawford. He is such a balanced fighter and he has not just beaten, but dominated, lots of good fighters through the years.
2: Wilder. His KO percentage is absolutely insane and he has defeated opponents such as Stiverne, Fury and Ortiz, who all have proven themselves as quality opposition. Not as balanced as Crawford, but his pure destructiveness makes him a clear number two, IMO.
3: Rigondeaux. He defeated a P4P top fighter in Donaire and his only loss came against a way bigger Lomachenko, who himself is a good boxer. He is a better boxer than Wilder, but I have him below him, as he is starting to get old.
4: Jacobs. He got robbed against Golovkin and Canelo. If the judges had been less influenced by the popularity of his opponents, Jacobs would have one of the best resumes in the entire sport at the moment. He lost to Pirog, fair and square, but that feels like ages ago and he has improved a lot since then.
5: Joshua. He was the big champ at heavyweight until his loss to Ruiz and I expect him to avenge the loss in the rematch. The loss was pretty bad, though, so I have him down at number 5 at the moment.

top 5 for holding up a liquor store? being on welfare? failing 6th grade for the seventh time? naming their kids a sound?

[Rusty Tromboni]

OP's list makes perfect sense once you see him. OP is comrade ****** on the far right.

sometimes I think the "rest of us" unwittingly stumbled onto a Down Low dating website.

[ShawnTaylor]

1) Loma
2) Fury
3) Usyk
4) Canelo
5) Golovkin


I had Golovkin winning both fights handedly. But his performance against the Ukrainian finally sinks him below canelo, whom he's beaten.

This is probably the worst P4P list in the entire thread.

Lomachenko hasn't done anything relevant for years, Golovkin never did anything relevant at all, Usyk dominated one of the weakest divisions in the entire sport, Fury lost to Wilder. Canelo is the only guy who belongs on the list and even that one is being generous.

[Dodger07]

1) Lomachenko
2) Canelo
3) Crawford
4) Usyk
5) Pacquiao

[Combat Talk Radio]

This is probably the worst P4P list in the entire thread.

Lomachenko hasn't done anything relevant for years, Golovkin never did anything relevant at all, Usyk dominated one of the weakest divisions in the entire sport, Fury lost to Wilder. Canelo is the only guy who belongs on the list and even that one is being generous.

WHERE people are in the list is a problem. WHO is on the list...well, wouldn't be mine, but at least there's no Crawford in the Top 5, so I'll let it go.

[FredRekk]

1) Lomachenko
2) Canelo
3) Crawford
4) Usyk
5) Pacquiao

Switch Loma and Pac and it’ll make more sense.