Does this make you reassess Judah's punch resistance in retrospect?

[Guest]

Seeing the man who shook Judah KO the "ultimate blood and guts warrior" last week has led me to wonder whether we've been unkind to Judah's punch resistance, particularly as his only KO loss came to a P4P puncher like Costa Zoo.

I note that he also suffered KDs against Jan Piet Bergman and Terron Millett.


Thoughts...?

[PATO 1]

and cory spinks an rafael pineda

[amagnin]

and cory spinks an rafael pineda

Baldomir does not have a great punch. He simply wore down Gatti by hitting him a lot. Gatti also is not what he was when he fought Mickey Ward... taking that much punishment takes something out of you as a fighter. For instance, I don't think Mosley would have KO'd Vargas as easily as he did if Vargas hadn't been through the wars he has. Being KO'd by Koz doesn't mean you have a glass jaw but it came in the 2nd round and it was 1 punch that dropped him. The knockdowns earlier in his career confirm his questiionable chin. The real kicker is that he was KO'd by Cory Spinks. I have never seen Spinks drop a fighter with even a decent chin.

[TheGreat1]

and cory spinks an rafael pineda

and Chop Chop

[PATO 1]

i never mentioned gatti or baldo

[amagnin]

i never mentioned gatti or baldo

Sorry I was acutally responding to the initial post on the thread and agreeing with your point about Spinks.

[GunStar]

Seeing the man who shook Judah KO the "ultimate blood and guts warrior" last week has led me to wonder whether we've been unkind to Judah's punch resistance, particularly as his only KO loss came to a P4P puncher like Costa Zoo.

I note that he also suffered KDs against Jan Piet Bergman and Terron Millett.


Thoughts...?

He's never been knocked out, he got TKO by Tszyu, Nady stopped the fight after Judah jumped up to quickly for the chiken dance.

Judah doesn't have good chin, but he's never been knocked out.

[PATO 1]

i think pbf was about 2 stop him

[amagnin]

i think pbf was about 2 stop him

If not for the low-blow...PBF stops him.

[Guest]

PBF was verging on stopping him, I agree, though his power hasn't really carried up, has it?