Who has been fighting the best competition over the last few years?

[amagnin]

Yeah if its last 3 I go with Taylor but if we go back further you have to give it up for the Winkster. I really respect the fact that once he established himself he didn't do what other people did to him and duck.

[keystone30pack]

co-sign




this donkey knows his sport!

dammit charlie

and i burned you on that earlier scully thread

before i knew you were playin

we cool now

[keystone30pack]

bozo check our inbox

also whats your opinion?

[scap]

I think you can make a case for every guy on the list except for Antonio Tarver.

[charlie31]

I think you can make a case for every guy on the list except for Antonio Tarver.

um no, like him or not, he fought Roy, Johnson AND b-hop

[TheEvilSaint]

i say castillo. not only has he fought the best, hes done so very very actively. in 16 months (from june '04 to oct. '05) he had 5 consecutive fights against the best competition in his division, defeating every one of his opponents in those 16 months.

[scap]

um no, like him or not, he fought Roy, Johnson AND b-hop

Dont um boy me boy...

He fought Glenn Johnson twice...Glenn is a nice fighter who makes you work hard but by no means has he EVER been a huge road block.

Roy the first 2 times was great but the third fight should not be one that you blow a load over...it was easy money.

Why um boy me...its just not right.

[keystone30pack]

i say castillo. not only has he fought the best, hes done so very very actively. in 16 months (from june '04 to oct. '05) he had 5 consecutive fights against the best competition in his division, defeating every one of his opponents in those 16 months.

good point saint

as scap previously said

one can make a pretty good argument for any of the fighters listed

[amagnin]

Dont um boy me boy...

He fought Glenn Johnson twice...Glenn is a nice fighter who makes you work hard but by no means has he EVER been a huge road block.

Roy the first 2 times was great but the third fight should not be one that you blow a load over...it was easy money.

Why um boy me...its just not right.

Whoa... calm down Charlie doesn't mean it as an insult. It's just how he posts. And you are wrong... Tarver may not have the best resume but he most definitely deserves to be on there. When he fought RJJ the first 2 times he was considered top 3 in terms of p4p. He followed that up by fighting Johnson who had just KO'd RJJ. You are right that Johnson isn't flashy but check out his record and you will see he has got some bad decisions and fought really tough opposition. Top that off with Hopkins who was still high on the p4p list and I don't see your logic.

[charlie31]

Dont um boy me boy...

He fought Glenn Johnson twice...Glenn is a nice fighter who makes you work hard but by no means has he EVER been a huge road block.

Roy the first 2 times was great but the third fight should not be one that you blow a load over...it was easy money.

Why um boy me...its just not right.

says um, no




not um, boy