If Keith Thurman goes on to....

[KillaMane26]

Thurman was hurt in his last 6 fights prior to Pacquiao?
Well no $h!t Sherlock!
It’s combat sports!
People get hit and hurt, even when they win!
Doesn’t indicate ANYTHING!

He’s too inconsistent?
He was undefeated until Pacquiao fight! Can’t be any more consistent than being undefeated ya nerd!

Like I said!
Nonstop Excuses
TBE The Best Excuses

Lmao...

If we debating or comparing fighters common sense we gonna take into account every detail.

Every thing you say is soooo Black and white with no substance. Im breaking down the comparsion between Thurman and the other 3 but you disregarding those details.

U make no sense...Why would i not bring these things up if we comparing fighters ret@rd.

So its okay for you to bring up "who has Spence Crawford fought"

But i can't bring up Thurman inconsistencies?

U just made a thread about people not using facts...but how many facts have i brought up since i start arguing witcho ass?? But u choose to disregard anything that doesn't fit your agenda.

[KillaMane26]

Thurman was hurt in his last 6 fights prior to Pacquiao?
Well no $h!t Sherlock!
It’s combat sports!
People get hit and hurt, even when they win!
Doesn’t indicate ANYTHING!

He’s too inconsistent?
He was undefeated until Pacquiao fight! Can’t be any more consistent than being undefeated ya nerd!

Like I said!
Nonstop Excuses
TBE The Best Excuses

So who Spence and Crawford fought indicates things...

But "Who" hurt Thurman doesn't indicate anything??

Thurman got hurt by guys who wouldnt last 5rounds with EJ or TC.

But i guess them nonstop excuses too huh? Lmao

[Unified18]

Brook wasnt damaged goods when he ****ing Spence up, and that eye wasnt the same eye that guy destroyed in that fight.

I used to feel like Thurman was 50-50 with Spence. But lets be honest even though him (and DSG) have the better resume, he is the most vulnerable out of the 3. He has been hurt in almost all his last 6 fights even before his layoff.

And he seems to not be as focused mentally compared to the other two. Thurman aint mentally consistent and it shows. If he was i would give him the edge over Spence cuz of his style. But this guy was letting Manny steal rounds by taking the first half round off then exploding the last minute( which Spence brought up)

Thurman too inconsistent

Brooks was damaged, the damage GGG did forced Brook's surgeon to insert a metal bar into Brooks' damaged, right orbital bone while his left orbital bone was left untouched. Having a metal bar on one side and none on the other, caused Brooks' entire orbital bone foundation to weaken (according to his surgeon) which Spence no doubt benefited from during his fight.

[_original_]

Keith Thurman is shot, which is why both are clearly better.

A close loss to Pacquiao is not better than knocking out Jeff Horn or knocking out Kell Brook.

Yes, it is.

[ELPacman]

Thurman is still more dynamic than most of the upper 147lbers. More dimensions than D. Garcia and Porter. I would love to see Thurman against Crawford and Spence Jr.

[KillaMane26]

Brooks was damaged, the damage GGG did forced Brook's surgeon to insert a metal bar into Brooks' damaged, right orbital bone while his left orbital bone was left untouched. Having a metal bar on one side and none on the other, caused Brooks' entire orbital bone foundation to weaken (according to his surgeon) which Spence no doubt benefited from during his fight.

Can u agree that. Brook was his toughest fight and if Spence wasnt so relentless Brook woulda won?

Of course that fight gonna have * beside it from the GGG fight but we can't disregard Spence weathering the storm (Brooks offense) and stopping him

[Unified18]

Can u agree that. Brook was his toughest fight and if Spence wasnt so relentless Brook woulda won?

Of course that fight gonna have * beside it from the GGG fight but we can't disregard Spence weathering the storm (Brooks offense) and stopping him

Prior to the round when Spence broke his eye socket I actually had the fight 3-3, maybe even 4-2 for Brooks, had Spence fought the pre GGG Brook I doubt Spence would have broke Brook's eye socket which was a really huge part of Spence 2nd half dominance of that fight. I still favour Spence to eventually win a close decision against a healthy Brooks, but I don't think that fight is indicative that Spence is head and shoulders above the PBC, welterweight stable, his fight with a healthy Porter should give a much clearer understanding where he stand however.

Crawford has been a bum killer in the 140 and 147, we seen many fighters look terrific against mediocre oppositions in the past, only to look very human once they step up the competition (prince Naseem comes to mind). He certainly looks like the real deal don't get me wrong, but we still need to see how he performs against the other talented WW in the Div.

[KillaMane26]

Prior to the round when Spence broke his eye socket I actually had the fight 3-3, maybe even 4-2 for Brooks, had Spence fought the pre GGG Brook I doubt Spence would have broke Brook's eye socket which was a really huge part of Spence 2nd half dominance of that fight. I still favour Spence to eventually win a close decision against a healthy Brooks, but I don't think that fight is indicative that Spence is head and shoulders above the PBC, welterweight stable, his fight with a healthy Porter should give a much clearer understanding where he stand however.

Crawford has been a bum killer in the 140 and 147, we seen many fighters look terrific against mediocre oppositions in the past, only to look very human once they step up the competition (prince Naseem comes to mind). He certainly looks like the real deal don't get me wrong, but we still need to see how he performs against the other talented WW in the Div.

Facts. He looks great but his best win at 147 is Amir-Con and overall Gamboa. Arum needs to get him a decent opponent before fighting Spence cuz these guys he fighting are not keeping him sharp for the top 147lbers.