I made a very similar thread to this about 2 years ago, so I know where you're coming from. What's youre seeing is the same as me, that hes not super gifted in single areas, but I'm sold on him now. His gift is how many boxes he checks, his consistency, his mental and physical stamina, his IQ, ability to control distance, great jab and body punching. The fact that hes a big WW def works for him and makes him more formidable. I used to think TC would beat him clearly, now I think it's a close fight, but I still like Crawford.
He is definitely heavy handed, and fighters with a less than elite chin/stamina will get stopped by him imo. Someone like Porter is prob a 12 round fight.
The main thing for me is how other fighters and trainers talk about him that have seen him up close and personal in training/sparring. It's not the way they praise him, but everyone talks about him like he is a daunting task. Leonard Ellerbe is super defensive over anything Floyd related, always has been, if you watch his interview about the sparring sessions with Floyd-Spence, if you read between the lines, you can tell Spence put it on Floyd, and that is more or less in line with what everyone else says who was there.
He is definitely heavy handed, and fighters with a less than elite chin/stamina will get stopped by him imo. Someone like Porter is prob a 12 round fight.
The main thing for me is how other fighters and trainers talk about him that have seen him up close and personal in training/sparring. It's not the way they praise him, but everyone talks about him like he is a daunting task. Leonard Ellerbe is super defensive over anything Floyd related, always has been, if you watch his interview about the sparring sessions with Floyd-Spence, if you read between the lines, you can tell Spence put it on Floyd, and that is more or less in line with what everyone else says who was there.

Comment