Comments Thread For: Latest 147 Conquest Adds New Layer To Pac-Mayweather Debate

[thedarkdragon11]

TBE (not The Best Ever) is the better fighter (skill-wise)... GrandPac is the greater fighter (legacy-wise)...

[lutenco]

LMAOOOOO, you say Floyd struggled with Castillo but you say "undeserved victory" for Pacquiao with JMM 3...call it as both are ROBBERIES, Floyd lost and Manny lost....Cotto at 154 was in a terrible moment of his career and you have the nerve to give credit to Floyd for that victory? Wow just wow, also Trout beat Cotto few months later and Cotto was coming from fights over Mayorga (no comment) and a rematch with Margarito with one eye because Manny almost killed hin, smh and shame on the writer of this article as always.... , the victory of Manny at 147 in 2009 over Cotto was way far more impressive, etc etc etc After all these years i open boxingcene and yet i found a biased article of this XXXXX. LMAOOOOO

[twosweethooks]

Floyd Joy Mayweather 😂

Get to the chase:

Castillo BEAT Joy JR by 2-3 rounds but naturally was ROBBED of the win😂

ODH was old out of Prime but still beat Joy Jr and Naturally was ROBBED of the win.

Joy went on extended Vacations when challenged by Margarito nearly messing his panties upon approach!!! He went the other way plus he got mad when challenged to fight the UNDEFEATED COTTO!!!

The whole problem with Floyd Joy Mayweather JR is WHEN he fought who he fought:

The champs were OLD, had problems, little, wee little etc...

Joy Jr never had the balls to fight another PRIME UNDEFEATED ELITE!!

Somebody should confute what I just said !!!!

Let’s make this easy😂😂👏👏👏👏

Somebody Name the UNDEFEATED PRIME ELITE WELTERWEIGHT with NO hindrances that Joy Jr fought in the last 15 years !!😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏

[jdp28tx]

Dude said ignore the results of a fight because it was boring..... classic ignorance.

Are you a moron or what. I never said ignore the results. I usually don't pick fights with people with Downs Syndrome,but the comment obviously went way over your head. Maybe when your case worker shows up at your adult group home you can ask him or her to teach you how to read at a higher level than the 6th grade. And maybe ask her to help you look up the definition of the word ignorance while you are at in since you do not even know how to use the word in the proper context.

[Thaman2x]

Floyd Joy Mayweather 😂

Get to the chase:

Castillo BEAT Joy JR by 2-3 rounds but naturally was ROBBED of the win😂

ODH was old out of Prime but still beat Joy Jr and Naturally was ROBBED of the win.

Joy went on extended Vacations when challenged by Margarito nearly messing his panties upon approach!!! He went the other way plus he got mad when challenged to fight the UNDEFEATED COTTO!!!

The whole problem with Floyd Joy Mayweather JR is WHEN he fought who he fought:

The champs were OLD, had problems, little, wee little etc...

Joy Jr never had the balls to fight another PRIME UNDEFEATED ELITE!!

Somebody should confute what I just said !!!!

Let’s make this easy😂😂👏👏👏👏

Somebody Name the UNDEFEATED PRIME ELITE WELTERWEIGHT with NO hindrances that Joy Jr fought in the last 15 years !!😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏

Your alternative facts are quite askew. Floyd had a choice regarding Margarito Fight Oscar De La Hoya for the 154lb title, for 20 million and an overall GREATER name to add to his resume or Margo, who lost to a green Paul Williams, a C level fighter in Daniel Santos, and only for 8 million. Seems to me, like Floyd made the right Business AND Career decision.

You have no critique of Pacquiao fighting the majority of Mayweather's leftovers...Why? Like dude....We wouldn't even be having this discussion TODAY if Pacquiao lost Saturday.

[nalamboxing]

Wow sooo many Pacman fanboy tryna disregard Floyd. I love both of these fighters but let’s not act Floyd in 2015 or 2016 would put on masterclass against Thurman of those years. Thurman was inactive with two years and his right hand isn’t the same anymore after having a surgery on it, but I gave Pac alot of credit as did everyone else. But we get hung up on the P4P talk way too much and don’t assess things on a skill for skill basis. Floyd would’ve been simply more skilled and neutralized any version of Pac due to being a bit bigger and smarter , having the better jab and footwork. Both legends and p4p Manny may even be greater. But in the ATG list, Floyd is ahead.

[mmamachine]

Ffs used to like your articles this one is a pile of **** though. Maytard fan all the way.
I'm not the opposite, not a ******* fan boy I appreciate boxing but you've just lost my respect.

[mmamachine]

And yeah Floyd lost to Castillo.
Got loads of respect for him after that but he did lose.

[The Big Dunn]

Lyle, like most credible media members, is an employed writer who gets paid. There is a huge difference in responsibility when writing an article for a major site with your name, credibility, and employment on the line then there is giving an opinion under an anonymous screen name on a website.

Just put their resumes under the same microscope. Manny gets absolute credit for fights he had at the lower weights. He deserves credit for winning titles in 8 divisions.

The difference between the groups is Floyd fans give Manny fair credit for his accomplishments while Manny fans refuse to give Floyd credit for his.

[pedrito]

Wow this article is trash! To be fair Lyle has been riding Mayweather's junk forever, so I should have seen this coming... dunno why I clicked the link.