Lets settle it. Which win was more impressive?Floyd vs Canelo or Pacquiao vs Thurman?

[FredRekk]

PAC vs. Thurman and it’s not even close. Close thread, there’s nothing to debate.

[FredRekk]

Floyd's win is looking better and better

Serafim’s win is looking better and better!

[FinitoxDinamita]

Pac > Thurman is way more impressive.

[hugh grant]

Pac > Thurman is way more impressive.

Pac beating thurman is obviously better historically. What Pac did has not been done in history.
Floyd beat canel o in flouds 4th weight class with cw? What's so good about that? Has that not been done in history or something?

[Skip Bayless]

Lmao without a doubt it’s Floyd, looking at the results just shows how many pac fans are on this site.

Canelo is by far the superior win, floyd was 36 when he whooped his ass and outweighed by around 20lbs. Thurman was a broken has been when pac beat him, a good win considering pac age but he ain’t no Canelo

To everyone *****ing about catchweights, i guess pac win over cotto and margarito don’t mean nothing right?

[FredRekk]

Lmao without a doubt it’s Floyd, looking at the results just shows how many pac fans are on this site.

Canelo is by far the superior win, floyd was 36 when he whooped his ass and outweighed by around 20lbs. Thurman was a broken has been when pac beat him, a good win considering pac age but he ain’t no Canelo

To everyone *****ing about catchweights, i guess pac win over cotto and margarito don’t mean nothing right?

Your name is Skip Bayless.
All your credibility goes out the window jabroni.

[Skip Bayless]

Reading this thread smh I’m embarrassed.

Apparently Keith was in his prime when pac beat him lmao the mental gymnastics pac fans make, not only is Canelo the better win in case u lot forgot floyd beat pac EASY so just stop already and accept your boy is no2 and move on

[hugh grant]

Thurman a good win considering pac age but he ain’t no Canelo

To everyone *****ing about catchweights, i guess pac win over cotto and margarito don’t mean nothing right?

Ain't no canelo? Nel o had no good wins when he fought floyd, it was a CW also. How can it be a great win with a cw? Pac s win over thurman is greater in all departments but especially historically speaking
Pac s win over cott o and margarita isn't great, but at least Pac stopped cotto. But actually cott o was Pac s 7th or 8th weight class, so it's greater than floyd cw against nel o for sure. Did Floyd stop nel o or cotto? Did Floyd fight margarito?

[FredRekk]

This is a silly debate.
Of course it’s Pacquiao.

Canelo was green and not even nearly as good as he is today or 3 years ago for that matter.

40 year old senator part time boxer outclassed undefeated PRIME Thurman.

Pacs win was incredibly more impressive. Sheesh. Some of you folks need your head checked.

[Joe Beamish]

Pacquiao actually hurt Thurman a couple times, including a knockdown and a fantastic body shot that was agonizing, and sent Thurman running for his life.

Mayweather outboxed a pup. He was dominant from a points perspective but it wasn’t really a FIGHT.