Pacquiao or Thurman - Who has the better resume from 2016-present?

[Ca$ual Fan]

Before these two fighters meet in the ring and take each other as part of their resume

Discuss

[_Rexy_]

I guess it depends how highly you rate Tim Bradley

[Ca$ual Fan]

I guess it depends how highly you rate Tim Bradley

Idk I kinda rate the undefeated D. Garcia slightly higher maybe but I definitely rate the undefeated Bradley higher

[R_Walken]

It’s Thurman hands down

Thurman: Beat Porter & Garcia when they were both top 5 / Prime & he took Danny’s 0

PAC - No one from 2016 onwards was a top 5 WW. Decent collection of names that’s all

[j.razor]

When Keith beats Manny it will be Keith.

[Ca$ual Fan]

It’s Thurman hands down

Thurman: Beat Porter & Garcia when they were both top 5 / Prime & he took Danny’s 0

PAC - No one from 2016 onwards was a top 5 WW. Decent collection of names that’s all

If we base solely on quality, yes Thurman no doubt. But if we quantify it, Pac has more fights to add up. Pac also has the Bradley win, a top 5 WW. That alone can be compared to either Garcia and Porter.

To me,

Garcia is slightly above Bradley because of Garcia's '0'
Porter over Horn
Broner equivalent to Josesito

but then, there are still

Vargas - a top 10 WW, arguably top 5 when Pac fought him
Matthysse - yes he's shot but still a good addition for anybody's resume nonetheless

If we quantify them along with quality, I think they're pretty even.

[KTFOKING]

It’s Thurman hands down

Thurman: Beat Porter & Garcia when they were both top 5 / Prime & he took Danny’s 0

PAC - No one from 2016 onwards was a top 5 WW. Decent collection of names that’s all

Pacquiao beat Bradley who was a top 5 WW.

[boliodogs]

When Keith beats Manny it will be Keith.

The proper word would be IF Thurman beats Manny. Thurman is the betting underdog not the favorite.

[KTFOKING]

The proper word would be IF Thurman beats Manny. Thurman is the betting underdog not the favorite.

Meh, the true odds reflected him being the favorite as that is what it opened as but majority of the bets have come Pacquiao's way making him the slight favorite.

Not too uncommon for Pacman fights. Look at the odds that opened up for Mayweather vs Pacquiao and then see what they were the day of the fight.

[j.razor]

The proper word would be IF Thurman beats Manny. Thurman is the betting underdog not the favorite.

Negative, its when. I can see what's going on..