No debate who can match Canelos resume

[robertzimmerman]

It really depends on your personal preferences as a fan. I don't think Loma or Crawford have nearly the resume that Canelo does. But I also think Crawford is the most physically gifted of the 3, and Loma is technically the best boxer of the 3.

So all 3 have a case IMO. In 20 years though, who is going to be remembered most? I think that it is Canelo no doubt, he's writing a Hall of Fame career and could go down as an all time top 20 P4P guy, maybe higher.

Great points Johnny, but let's calm down just a little.

An all time top 20, P4P fighter, or even HIGHER?

That's a huge statement to make at this stage. Huge.

Let's get some perspective:

He's just had a very good win over a very good fighter in Jacobs. But Jacobs isn't great. And he's just had 2 very close fights with GG. He's got an awful long way to go before he'll be held in such high regard.

[robertzimmerman]

I give praise to a guy who nobody BUT the best can beat.

What part of that isn't getting across?

Stop embarrassing yourself.

[Ca$ual Fan]

Height and reach always matter

You don't know about this.

Donaire is smaller than Loma and less strong

Loma had all the advantages against Rigo

And that fight was a fuc.king garbage , totally boring

The fight of Khan vs Canelo was a garbage I never mentioned that fight as a good thing to canelos career

And I respecto Khan because he fought with a lot of great rivals

The Canelo vs Khan fight was definitely a garbage.

While Loma vs Rigo turned out to be a boring fight, it was definitely an intriguing fight to see before the result

[Ca$ual Fan]

Beating guys in and around your weight class >>>>>>>> Beating guys 2 divisions lower than you

Spence vs Garcia

Crawford vs Khan

Give me your thoughts

[mcdonalds]

Spence vs Garcia

Crawford vs Khan

Give me your thoughts

They aren't elite wins

[a5pe4]

You can debate where Canelo is P4P and you can debate who won his close fights. But you can't debate that he has fought the best names and has the strongest resume of any current fighter in boxing

[Ca$ual Fan]

They aren't elite wins

Whose win weighs more? Spence or Crawford?

[robertzimmerman]

You can debate where Canelo is P4P and you can debate who won his close fights. But you can't debate that he has fought the best names and has the strongest resume of any current fighter in boxing

He's got a very good resume, but that's a big call.

Manny hasn't retired yet, so obviously Manny has a superior resume.

Joshua also has a very good resume.

[ShoulderRoll]

He's got a very good resume, but that's a big call.

Manny hasn't retired yet, so obviously Manny has a superior resume.

Joshua also has a very good resume.

Joshua???

His best win is Klitschko. Who Tyson Fury beat first.

[robertzimmerman]

Joshua???

His best win is Klitschko. Who Tyson Fury beat first.

Correct. But he has a good resume.

Wlad
Parker
Povetkin
Whyte
Brazeale
Takam

That's a pretty good resume at this stage.

Canelo has a very good resume. But Mosley was shot, Cotto and Khan weren't MW's, he lost emphatically to Floyd, and he was lucky to get results over Lara and GG.