The Best Top 10 P4P List?

[boliodogs]

Pretty good list.

Why? Because it's very close to the same as your list? Everyone's list is perfect FOR THEM.

[Nehnenqui]

Why? Because it's very close to the same as your list? Everyone's list is perfect FOR THEM.

Everyone’s list is good except yours. Yours is the worst.

[Ca$ual Fan]

1. Canelo
2. Spence
3. Crawford
4. Inoue
5. Estrada
6. Usyk
7. M. Garcia
8. Jacobs
9. Lomachenko
10. Nietes

Some few things of note:

So Jacobs and Estrada got robbed by GGG and SSR respectively in your book?

Spence should have eliminated Mikey off the list because he beat him pound for pound way not because he used his size.

Loma seems like an underachiever to you

[El Gitano]

Based on the replies, this is the P4P list based on averages:

1. Canelo
2. Crawford
3. Lomachenko
4. Usyk
5. Spence
6. Inoue
7. GGG
8. M. Garcia
9. Rungvisai
10. Jacobs

['b']

The best top 10 p4p list? One with David Lemieux, Dominic Wade and Kell Brook apparently

[Nehnenqui]

Some few things of note:

So Jacobs and Estrada got robbed by GGG and SSR respectively in your book?

Spence should have eliminated Mikey off the list because he beat him pound for pound way not because he used his size.

Loma seems like an underachiever to you

No problem with the official decisions but I think Estrada beat SSR and Gonzalez, which is why I rate him so high.

No problem with the GGG vs. Jacobs decision, that was a close fight. I think Jacobs has done more than Golovkin since their fight, which is why I have him in the Top 10. He beat three solid undefeated fighters while Golovkin went 0-1-1 against Canelo and beat Martirosyan.

If Golovkin comes back and beats someone legit I’d give him that 10 spot over Nietes. If he fights a nobody he stays off the list.

Loma and Garcia are in a weak division and have been in fairly weak divisions their whole careers. That’s why I have them so low. Garcia is ahead of Lomachenko because he has a deeper resume overall and I have no doubt he’d starch Lomachenko in a fight.

[Nehnenqui]

Based on the replies, this is the P4P list based on averages:

1. Canelo
2. Crawford
3. Lomachenko
4. Usyk
5. Spence
6. Inoue
7. GGG
8. M. Garcia
9. Rungvisai
10. Jacobs

That’s a real good list.

[TheBoxingBanger]

If that's your list....

Cool, but how is Mikey on there but GGG isn't?

Mikey lost every round on every card. P4P material should have shown us something ....

GGG still hasn't been soundly beat. He beat Canelo the 1st time, the second fight I got no problem with it being a draw.

GGG should still be undefeated, with maybe a draw.

And he isn't on your list?

1. Canelo
2. Spence
3. Crawford
4. Inoue
5. Estrada
6. Usyk
7. M. Garcia
8. Jacobs
9. Lomachenko
10. Nietes

[CodeBreaker]

1. Canelo
2. Lomachenko
3. Crawford
4. Spence
5. Usyk
6. Joshua
7. Inoue
8. GGG
9. Jacobs
10. Pacquiao

[Ca$ual Fan]

No problem with the official decisions but I think Estrada beat SSR and Gonzalez, which is why I rate him so high.

No problem with the GGG vs. Jacobs decision, that was a close fight. I think Jacobs has done more than Golovkin since their fight, which is why I have him in the Top 10. He beat three solid undefeated fighters while Golovkin went 0-1-1 against Canelo and beat Martirosyan.

If Golovkin comes back and beats someone legit I’d give him that 10 spot over Nietes. If he fights a nobody he stays off the list.

Loma and Garcia are in a weak division and have been in fairly weak divisions their whole careers. That’s why I have them so low. Garcia is ahead of Lomachenko because he has a deeper resume overall and I have no doubt he’d starch Lomachenko in a fight.

Fair enough for Estrada

As for GGG, he may be 0-1-1 but if we are going to use the logic you used for Estrada, we could also make a case (based on other’s views) that he’s 2-0 against Canelo. That plus the Martirosyan win, makes him 3-0. Then he could easily have Canelo’s place in p4p rankings. Jacobs being in that place, just makes GGG’s rankings more solidified.

I think I disagree with the Mikey-Loma resume comparisons. Plus Mikey beating Loma is still a theory not a fact. Mikey is in a downside right now. Also Spence, as I mentioned earlier, kicked him off the list already. It’s Mikey’s burden now to prove to us that he still belong to the elites with his comeback attempt.