Kell Brook has been so poorly managed/matched through his career.

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • W1LL
    Celtic Warrior
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Dec 2004
    • 11851
    • 845
    • 916
    • 71,119

    #1

    Kell Brook has been so poorly managed/matched through his career.

    It is bad. Dang. I feel bad for this guy. 5-10 years ago this guy looked super, super talented. Not talking hype, but genuinely talented. I feel that he was a victim of Anthony Joshua's success.

    Kell was a beast and switched from Frank Warren to Eddie Hearn. Everyone in Britain was in agreement that he was a World champion in the making. He was the best fighter in the Matchroom stable. But as soon as AJ came along he took a backseat, and getting him his shot became less of a priority.

    From 2014, it's as though Brook became more of a side quest for Matchroom. When he won that IBF title against Shawn Porter, he finally reached the status that the majority had been expecting for years. It was more of a "what took so long?" than anything else. From there he should have pushed on and looked for the big fights, or moved up to Super Welterweight. At least should have established himself Stateside.

    But again, at a time when AJ was blasting through journeymen, and capturing the IBF title off Charles Martin, Brook fought some of the softest opposition available, on small shows with poor supporting cards. The best card he fought on also had Selby-Gradovich and Linares-Mitchell, but Brook's opponent was Frankie Gavin!

    Kell had been struggling to make the weight since before the first Carson Jones fight, it was no secret. He should have moved up soon after capturing the World title. But fighting Gennady Golovkin, at Middleweight was career suicide. I still cannot fathom why Eddie Hearn fed Brook to Golovkin. It is almost like he wanted rid of him.

    At 30 years old, 36-0 (25 KO), the IBF World Welterweight champion, Brook should have been looking to step up to Super Welterweight/Light Middleweight and position himself for a title shot there. At the time Jermell Charlo held the WBC, Jermall Charlo the IBF, Liam Smith the WBO, and Erislandy Lara the WBA World. Would have made more sense having Canelo vs. GGG then, and Brook vs. Smith. But instead we got Canelo vs. Smith and GGG vs. Brook.

    Brook shouldn't have fought GGG, no other way to say it. Fighting Errol Spence 9 months later, in his comeback fight, fresh off surgery to fix a broke eye socket, in a division 13lb below his last fight, when he'd struggled to make that weight for years, again another WTF moment. Spence was pretty unknown in the UK, but still, Brook had no business returning to Welterweight after moving up to Middleweight.

    In interviews Hearn would say "Well... if he wants to go back to Welterweight, what can I do?" Smirking all the while. After almost getting retired by GGG in a fight he never should have took, he should have taken a year out, vacated his IBF belt, and looked to come back at Super Welter. Not rush back against a young killer like Spence at a weight he can barely make. Madness.

    Anyway, I'm rambling. Brook is shot now and took life-altering damage in both of those fights. When he retires as a one-time Welterweight champion of the World, it almost feels like he didn't fulfill his potential. Seeing him flatten Amir Khan was also a mouth-watering prospect, but even that now looks like it won't happen. At this point there's no guarentee he'd beat Khan if they end up fighting. It really is a shame, because a lot of people had great expectations when it came to Kell Brook.
    Last edited by W1LL; 03-24-2019, 10:21 AM.
  • Kaspa9t9
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Aug 2009
    • 2539
    • 104
    • 272
    • 26,224

    #2
    Warren did a terrible job with him. He was with him for almost a decade and never headlined or fought any meaningful fights. I remember seeing him on an undercard back in 2007 where he looked really good. I've been following him since but couldn't understand why fish eyes couldn't get him a decent dancing partner.

    Comment

    • Bullrider
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • May 2011
      • 5328
      • 518
      • 137
      • 13,616

      #3
      He put all his eggs in one Khan basket. That's his mistake.

      Comment

      • Diegosome1
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Nov 2016
        • 761
        • 37
        • 60
        • 21,944

        #4
        Good post. Agreed.

        Comment

        • Pago007
          Interim Champion
          • Nov 2011
          • 858
          • 70
          • 5
          • 16,690

          #5
          He took a chance moving up was always a big lad for 47 anyhow. Didnt pan out but at least he tried. Still my favourite fighter

          Comment

          • pillowfists98
            The Takeover 2020
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Jun 2018
            • 6685
            • 148
            • 81
            • 93,444

            #6
            I think people criticize Brook too much. Its pretty obvious that Khan never wanted to fight him.

            Comment

            • PsychoPat
              Banned
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Aug 2017
              • 4439
              • 180
              • 7
              • 12,785

              #7
              Originally posted by W1LL
              It is bad. Dang. I feel bad for this guy. 5-10 years ago this guy looked super, super talented. Not talking hype, but genuinely talented. I feel that he was a victim of Anthony Joshua's success.

              Kell was a beast and switched from Frank Warren to Eddie Hearn. Everyone in Britain was in agreement that he was a World champion in the making. He was the best fighter in the Matchroom stable. But as soon as AJ came along he took a backseat, and getting him his shot became less of a priority.

              From 2014, it's as though Brook became more of a side quest for Matchroom. When he won that IBF title against Shawn Porter, he finally reached the status that the majority had been expecting for years. It was more of a "what took so long?" than anything else. From there he should have pushed on and looked for the big fights, or moved up to Super Welterweight. At least should have established himself Stateside.

              But again, at a time when AJ was blasting through journeymen, and capturing the IBF title off Charles Martin, Brook fought some of the softest opposition available, on small shows with poor supporting cards. The best card he fought on also had Selby-Gradovich and Linares-Mitchell, but Brook's opponent was Frankie Gavin!

              Kell had been struggling to make the weight since before the first Carson Jones fight, it was no secret. He should have moved up soon after capturing the World title. But fighting Gennady Golovkin, at Middleweight was career suicide. I still cannot fathom why Eddie Hearn fed Brook to Golovkin. It is almost like he wanted rid of him.

              At 30 years old, 36-0 (25 KO), the IBF World Welterweight champion, Brook should have been looking to step up to Super Welterweight/Light Middleweight and position himself for a title shot there. At the time Jermell Charlo held the WBC, Jermall Charlo the IBF, Liam Smith the WBO, and Erislandy Lara the WBA World. Would have made more sense having Canelo vs. GGG then, and Brook vs. Smith. But instead we got Canelo vs. Smith and GGG vs. Brook.

              Brook shouldn't have fought GGG, no other way to say it. Fighting Errol Spence 9 months later, in his comeback fight, fresh off surgery to fix a broke eye socket, in a division 13lb below his last fight, when he'd struggled to make that weight for years, again another WTF moment. Spence was pretty unknown in the UK, but still, Brook had no business returning to Welterweight after moving up to Middleweight.

              In interviews Hearn would say "Well... if he wants to go back to Welterweight, what can I do?" Smirking all the while. After almost getting retired by GGG in a fight he never should have took, he should have taken a year out, vacated his IBF belt, and looked to come back at Super Welter. Not rush back against a young killer like Spence at a weight he can barely make. Madness.

              Anyway, I'm rambling. Brook is shot now and took life-altering damage in both of those fights. When he retires as a one-time Welterweight champion of the World, it almost feels like he didn't fulfill his potential. Seeing him flatten Amir Khan was also a mouth-watering prospect, but even that now looks like it won't happen. At this point there's no guarentee he'd beat Khan if they end up fighting. It really is a shame, because a lot of people had great expectations when it came to Kell Brook.
              Great post will mate, completely agree. On the topic of khan any word on how his training has been going? Crawford fight is in april right? I wonder if he's taken camp serious or just tryna make as much £ as he can then *** off lol. I agree he wont fight brook after all of there back n forth. Just hot air init.

              I got more chance of getting noshed off by khans missus then that fight happening.

              Comment

              • CasperUK
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jun 2005
                • 1373
                • 346
                • 427
                • 18,062

                #8
                He stayed at WW because he wanted the Khan fight - a guy naturally smaller than him - to cash out. That speaks volumes about his mindset.

                Khan pursued the best out there

                Froch pursued the best out there

                Joshua is pursuing the best out there

                Kell wanted the easy match(es).

                Comment

                • KingKrypton
                  Interim Champion
                  • Oct 2015
                  • 588
                  • 46
                  • 0
                  • 25,177

                  #9
                  He's like a crazy ex that can't let you go. Always thinking about bumming Khan.

                  Comment

                  • DuckAdonis
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Jul 2017
                    • 7775
                    • 197
                    • 84
                    • 188,446

                    #10
                    Yeah they ruined his career by letting him fight Golovkin. ******ed idea. Just look how great he did vs Spence after that. Showed how talented he really is, now that we know how good Spence is. Also is the only one to beat Porter clearly

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP