Who's a tougher fight for Thurman: Porter or Pacquiao

[South Champion]

Thurman has been mentioning that for his next opponent he'd like either Pacquiao or Porter.

Which is the more difficult fight for him?

[pillowfists98]

I would say Porter. He was off tonight, but I think he would bring his A game for a Thurman rematch.

[Curtis Harper]

Porter because he's so damned sloppy and wild.

[_original_]

I think Thurman beats Porter easily in a rematch, boring dominant UD. Pacquiao fight is more interesting.

[MulaKO]

Pac would be the harder fight for Thurman
Pac coming at you from all angles , might even be too much for Thurman’s style

[lizard_man]

Pacquiao beats thurman

[boliodogs]

Based off their last fights Pacquiao has a good chance to beat either of them even at age 40. Both Thurman and Porter looked lousy and Pacquiao still looked sharp. I think Pacquiao would be a harder fight for Thurman than Porter but unless Thurman improves a lot from the Lopez fight Porter might beat him too. Spence and Crawford are a class above the other welterweights to me. The others have all seen better days.