Comments Thread For: Teddy Atlas Back Judges: They Got it Right, Harrison Beat Charlo!

[SHOOTALLCLOWNS]

agree with atlas. harrison landed the cleaner more impressive shots. charlo looked sloppy and slow.

[STREET CLEANER]

I like the Charlo brothers & I think the judges got it right in both fights.

That is fine if you think that way. Some posters here don't like a boxer and sometimes won't give credit to them

[Bronx2245]

Ha, well 'spectacular' is kinda subjective ain't it? For me all you need to do is land more (and more telling) shots on your opponent than they land on you, and the style, the strategy and tactics employed to achieve that are largely irrelevant as long as that end is accomplished.

Individual cases I ain't gonna get into but let's just say I agree with some, but not all of your assessments!

Well, in that case Jermell wins, because Jermell landed 160 to Tony's 128. Jermell also threw more; 548 to 347, and Jermell landed 108 power punches (49.1) to Tony's 71 (38.6).

https://www.boxingscene.com/tony-harrison-vs-jermell-charlo-compubox-punch-stats--134891

However, three judges still saw Tony Harrison win, unanimously! It is what it is! It was a bad career move from jump! Marinating gone bad! Now the whole texture and flavor sucks! Hindsight is 20/20!

[Bronx2245]

Jeff beat Manny & Toney beat Jermell.

I can't rock wit' you on that!

[Citizen Koba]

Well, in that case Jermell wins, because Jermell landed 160 to Tony's 128. Jermell also threw more; 548 to 347, and Jermell landed 108 power punches (49.1) to Tony's 71 (38.6).

https://www.boxingscene.com/tony-harrison-vs-jermell-charlo-compubox-punch-stats--134891

However, three judges still saw Tony Harrison win, unanimously! It is what it is! It was a bad career move from jump! Marinating gone bad! Now the whole texture and flavor sucks! Hindsight is 20/20!

Ha. That wasn't the one I was disagreeing with, man. Matter of fact I didn't actually score it - watched both the Charlo fights in the a.m over breakfast and just got a rough feel for 'em. I was thinking a draw seemed about right for both, maybe leaning a lil more towards the Twins in both fights on first viewing - a lil more towards Korobov vs Jermall when I watched that one again.

S'all good though.. I ain't really fussed by how other people score fights and there's nothing more futile than arguing over it.

[rickJen]

Been a Charlo sisters critic.
But no, Harrison didn't win.
He was hardly throwing any punches for 12 effing rounds.
One of the most boring fights I've seen.
Atlas is wrong.

[Bronx2245]

Ha. That wasn't the one I was disagreeing with, man. Matter of fact I didn't actually score it - watched both the Charlo fights in the a.m over breakfast and just got a rough feel for 'em. I was thinking a draw seemed about right for both, maybe leaning a lil more towards the Twins in both fights on first viewing - a lil more towards Korobov vs Jermall when I watched that one again.

S'all good though.. I ain't really fussed by how other people score fights and there's nothing more futile than arguing over it.

Happy Holidays to you & yours! Countdown to Pacquiao vs. Broner!

[Citizen Koba]

Happy Holidays to you & yours! Countdown to Pacquiao vs. Broner!

And to yourself and your loved ones. All the best for the coming year.