Watched Urango vs Ben Rabah again: scorecard

[Smokin']

9-3 for Hopkins my bad.

[Easy-E]

Diego, you usually calls **** like it is. You're not a Mayweather fan, but a realist. But...how'd you have the following:
Hatton - Collazo (I had it 7 rounds to 5 to Hatton)
Mayweather - Judah (say the KD counted) (7 to 5 for Mayweather)
Hopkins - Tarver (9-3 for Tarver)

What'd you have it?

And it would be 115-112 Floyd still won 8 rounds, but If your going to count the KD, take a point away from Judah for the low blow and rabbit punch.
thats how i see it.

[Smokin']

What'd you have Hopkins - Taylor and Castillo - Mayweather 1?

[Easy-E]

What'd you have Hopkins - Taylor and Castillo - Mayweather 1?

115-113 Taylor and 115-114 Mayweather (after watching it like 10 times) Mayweahter Castillo is the type of fight that kinda changes each time you watch it.

[Smokin']

115-113 Taylor and 115-114 Mayweather (after watching it like 10 times) Mayweahter Castillo is the type of fight that kinda changes each time you watch it.

Dude, that right there shows your flawed logic. Let me explain:

In Hopkins - Taylor 1 and 2 Taylor was the agressor while Hopkins was blocking, slipping alot and throwing counters. It was the same in Mayweather - Castillo 1 with Castillo as the agressor and Mayweather doing the slipping and parrying and throwing counter shots.

[DiegoFuego]

Diego, you usually calls **** like it is. You're not a Mayweather fan, but a realist. But...how'd you have the following:
Hatton - Collazo (I had it 7 rounds to 5 to Hatton)
Mayweather - Judah (say the KD counted) (7 to 5 for Mayweather)
Hopkins - Tarver (9-3 for Tarver)

What'd you have it?

Sorry I'm so late to see this.

I had it 115-112 for Hatton (7 rounds to 5 like you)

116-112 for Mayweather, might have been 117-111, neither counting the knockdown because the ref didn't acknowledge it. I remember I gave Judah at least 2 of the first 4 and one of the last 2, but not both 11 and 12. I think I gave him 1, 2, and 12 for sure and may or may not have given him the 4th round was it?

Hopkins-Tarver was a blowout. I think I gave Tarver 2 rounds, but I lost interest real easily that fight. I've been meaning to watch Mayweather-Judah and Tarver-Hopkins again anyway so if I do this week, I'll tell you how I scored it.

I like Mayweather, but I criticize him when I think he screws up. I do that with all the guys I like. I bash Toney harder than just about anybody for his weight issues and I'm a huge Toney fan. The reason Corrales is my favorite fighter is because ever since he revived his career in 03, he hasn't ****ed up yet other than going through with that 2nd Castillo fight.

[Smokin']

What about Mayweather - Castillo 1? And how do you think Mayweather - Hatton at 140 would play out? And have you watched more then 2 fights of Hatton?

[DiegoFuego]

Since you guys are talking about these fights, I had Hopkins-Taylor I as 115-113 for Taylor, but there was one round that was really close for me, maybe round 4, I don't remember that could have made it a draw. I could not see Hopkins winning the fight under any circumstances though. The rematch I had it 116-112 for Taylor, could agree with 115-113, but Taylor definitely won it.

Mayweather-Castillo I has always been a hard fight to score, but I've scored it unlike just about anybody else. Most guys have it for Mayweather or Castillo by about 4 points like 115-111 one way or the other. The score I kept coming up with when I scored it last summer and fall was actually a draw 113-113. Very odd fight, but Mayweather probably guaranteed himself no worse than a draw when he won 4-5 of the first 6 rounds.

[Smokin']

That's funny though, coming from a Castillo hater.

And Mayweather - Hatton? And have you seen more then 2 Hatton fights? Be honest....

[Easy-E]

Dude, that right there shows your flawed logic. Let me explain:

In Hopkins - Taylor 1 and 2 Taylor was the agressor while Hopkins was blocking, slipping alot and throwing counters. It was the same in Mayweather - Castillo 1 with Castillo as the agressor and Mayweather doing the slipping and parrying and throwing counter shots.

Basiclly when Hopkins was fighting, he was beating Taylor.
He gave up the fight in the first few rounds when he didnt even counter when he had the chances too.
Taylor landed his shots cleaner then Castillo did, and in most cases Floyd countered more effectivly then Hopkins did in their respective fights.