mayweather not #1 p4p?

[omegamale]

since so many people don't think that pbf deserves his p4p status then who should be #1 p4p?

[HendrixLove]

since so many people don't think that pbf deserves his p4p status then who should be #1 p4p?

Arturo Gatti

[SacTown1]

since so many people don't think that pbf deserves his p4p status then who should be #1 p4p?

who are these sick maniacs that don't think he's #1???

I hate the guy, but i'll cop to the fact that he's light-years ahead of any other prizefighter on the planet, in terms of skill, speed, combos, etc.

WInky can't be rated #2 after his methodical performance vs. Taylor...

I'm a hgue Barrera fan, but if he's #2, it's a very distant 2nd to PBF

Pacquaio, let's remember, was thoroughly out-boxed by Morales in their 1st fight, and drew vs. Marquez, he's a distant #3 or #4, depending on where you rate Wink, but he'll elevate to a solid #2 or #3 with a bad-ass win 2night....

Taylor's still too green to make the rankings....

Calzaghe has 1 quality win to his name, so he's top 10 at best...

and then there's the Chico/Castillo situation....

[PATO 1]

i dont see how after raheem beat Morales and before his fight with freitas how he werent in there

Pacman is there for beating a guy who was coming off a defeat , was weight drained

i know he beat MAB but this still should only give him about 6th imo

[ferocity]

Jermain Taylor #1, and stop saying this guy is green damn it, he knows what to do, he knows how to fight, he just doesn't stick to the plan, green are fighters who just start out as a pro boxer, of you can say he's green cause he hasn't been in a war or been tested, which Taylor has already been through all this so he ain't green no more.

**** man even some fighters that start out in the pro game sometime can't be called green because they are so skilled have had a lot of experiance as an amature that they have been in this situattion before that the pro is no differnt, of course few are that good right out the gates as a pro. But damn, im even getting ****en confused with all this mis-use of the word green and how people are throwing this word around that it has almost lost all meaning to me. Damn shame!

[Nacho_Analstain]

Arturo Gatti

u know the script,****in dam rite!

[restless_438]

Jermain Taylor #1, and stop saying this guy is green damn it, he knows what to do, he knows how to fight, he just doesn't stick to the plan, green are fighters who just start out as a pro boxer, of you can say he's green cause he hasn't been in a war or been tested, which Taylor has already been through all this so he ain't green no more.

**** man even some fighters that start out in the pro game sometime can't be called green because they are so skilled have had a lot of experiance as an amature that they have been in this situattion before that the pro is no differnt, of course few are that good right out the gates as a pro. But damn, im even getting ****en confused with all this mis-use of the word green and how people are throwing this word around that it has almost lost all meaning to me. Damn shame!

Wow... Jermain Taylor is not the #1 P4P fighter...

My P4P currently looks like this:

Tied for 1. Winky Wright, 50-3-1 (25) & Manny Pacquiao, 41-3-2 (32)
3. Floyd Mayweather, 36-0 (24)
4. Bernard Hopkins, 47-4-1 (32)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera, 62-4 (42)
6. Jermain Taylor, 25-0-1 (17)
7. Jose Luis Castillo, 54-7-1 (47)
8. Joe Calzaghe, 41-0 (31)
9. Ricky Hatton, 41-0 (30)
10. Rafael Marquez, 35-3 (31)