Pound for Pound for June

[Super_Lightweight]

Riku, you honestly made a horrible list so you should be more cool-headed about the flack you take for that. Shoulda just said these are your favorite fighters.

my p4p list:

Floyd Mayweather (in danger of losing this spot...all up to him though)
Manny Pacquiao (MAB, EM...that's two top 10 p4p guys right there)
Winky Wright (Tito, Mosley x2, D12 Taylor)
Jermain Taylor (two wins over Hops, who was number one p4p)
Jose L. Castillo (beat Chico, Casamayor, Diaz, Floyd in most ppl's view)
Ricky Hatton (Tszyu was top 5 p4p when Hatton stopped him)
Marco A. Barerra (has looked pretty good since the Pac loss)
Rafael Marquez (wins over Austin and Too Sharp make Raffy a big timer)
Diego Corrales (expect him to drop off the list soon)
Joe Calzaghe (Lacy was a top 5 168er, though not as good as thought)

just missing: Roman Karmazin, Martin Castillo, Antonio Margarito, Chris John

[OptimusWolf]

Ok I'll risk censure by puttin mine up with limited explanations

1) PBF (not faced good competition until Zab but that win keeps hime there for a bit longer)
2) Pac man (recent dominating wins over EM and MAB, enough said)
3) Winky Wright (If he'd have beaten Taylor clearly he would have made #2)
4) Jermain taylor (wins against Hopkins and a draw against Wright - refreshing that he takes 3 superfights in a row)
5) MAB (lost to Pac but gets 10/10 for past career and has done well since.
6) Calzaghe (only ever once looked like he could lose, destroyed Lacy needs one more biggish fight to get into top 5)
7) Marquez (best little guy around)
8) Hatton (beat Tszyu, unified, but razor thin victory against Collazo although that win could be proved to be better than originally thought if Collazo bounces back)
9) Castillo (can't make weight but career wins and best performance against PBF keep him in there. If he loses at 140 he'll drop out
10) Arce (perhaps a weak choice but I like him and he's on a huge KO filled unbeaten streak)

[King Koyle]

1.Floyd Mayweather
2.Winky Wright
3.Manny Pacquiao
4.Joe Calzaghe
5.Rafael Marquez
6.Ricky Hatton
7.Jermain Taylor
8.Marco Antonio Barrera
9.Bernard Hopkins
10.Diego Corrales

[xzworks]

what the ****? then you should have changed the name of the thread!LOL! roy jones? OMG!LOL!

i guess.............

YA'LL MUSTVE FORGOT!!!

[PATO 1]

what i dont understand is people have pacman at 2 based on his win over morales but people forget that Morales was coming off a loss was weight drained but nobody had Zahir Raheem in their list also before that he had been beaten by Morales an schooled against Marquez

[Super_Lightweight]

what i dont understand is people have pacman at 2 based on his win over morales but people forget that Morales was coming off a loss was weight drained but nobody had Zahir Raheem in their list also before that he had been beaten by Morales an schooled against Marquez

Raheem doesn't hold wins over MAB, nor did he draw with Marquez. He also ust lost to Popo Freitas. In other words, Pac's placement in the top 5 is based off of several fights, not just the EM one.

No one should have Corrales above Castillo. He was destroyed in their last fight. When you get KOd in your most recent fight by a fellow p4p member, you absolutely NEVER get to be ranked ahead of him. When Tarver KOd Roy, Roy was placed at number 4 or so while Tarver jumped Roy.

[bobson_215]

Lol

funny thread..

[AllEyesOpen]

1) Mayweather - He beat Judah, an he's Mayweather, so nuff' said
2) Wright - He beat taylor, at least in my eyes.
3) Pacman - simply cause he's Pacman so F#$k you if that's not good enough.
4) Taylor - He showed that he can hold his own with one of the Top p4p fighters in the world, & IMO he has the potential to move on up.
5) Calzaghe - He proved that he's someone we should give respect to, & I think he'd give problems to anyone else on this list close to his weight.
6) Barrera - I don't know, to me it just looks like he's got something left in the tank.
7) Castillo - everyone knows he's got skill, he better prove that he still has it, and stop fu$%in' around.
8) Hopkins - He's the best Light HW in the world & he proved it.
9) Juarez - He's got more potential then anyone on the list, he just needs to show it, we'll see in the MAB rematch.
10)Toney - Call me delusional, but I think that if Lights Out lost just a few pounds & trained hard, he'd give any HW problems.

[Pac Man Fan 83]

I have my list in my sig, but I'm not sure I'm happy with it.

I'll look at it.