Is Buddy Mcgirt overrated as a trainer?

[boxingfan420]

**** YES. ANYONE WATCH THE TARVER FIGHT? tARVER HAS GREAT PHYSICAL SKILLS and ability, but none of it showed against Hopkins. And yes BHop makes you look bad, but Tarver wasn't even trying. His training and mindset before the fight must have been some joke. Did he not know he was facing a boxing master? What an *******.

[Straw18]

Did he give Julio the same advice he gave Tarver going into the 12th?

[DeTomaso]

Did he give Julio the same advice he gave Tarver going into the 12th?

Yes.

He told Julio to jab more prior to the 10th round.
WTF!! The kid needed a KO!!

Only thing is, Julio was so beat down and exhausted by that point, it didn't matter what McGirt told him. It was also obvious Julio's conditioning wasn't what it should've been.

[Deeznuts]

I think his training career would go unoticed if Gatti loses to Baldomir.

[Sttuddahboy619]

Julio needed to go for the KO on his last fight,Mcgirt told him to keep jabing. I don't understand that!