Where do you have Mikey Garcia on your P4P list currently?

[Raggamuffin]

Look at it this way. The WBC made him vacate his title. Why do you think that is? It's because he was unable to defend it due to injury. I look at P4P rankings the same way. You have to defend your spot in the P4P rankings. If you aren't actively fighting, for whatever reason, you shouldn't be on that list.

Explain to me why other active fighters who are putting together a fantastic year should lose a spot in the top ten because of an injured Thurman? How is that fair? You having an inactive Thurman on the list is like penalizing a fighter who is putting together a great 2018 year, but instead of him on the list, it's Thurman.

It doesn't make Thurman any less of a fighter. It's just that he's injured, so he's lost a step in the rankings. He can easily get his spot back.

I'm sure plenty of others agree with me.

The one thing that has gotten me this far in life is not caring what others think or who agrees or disagrees with me.

You don’t get moved off of the pfp list because of injury. Nobody made him vacate. He did that on his own volition.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

My list:

1. Usyk



2-10 Who gives a shlt?

Ain't none of them beating Usyk and we all know...

To be the man, you got to beat the man...

[Tony Trick-Pony]

me as a unbias fan of the sport of boxing, I see no other place to rank Mikey Garcia other than the #1 spot. No other active boxer has came close to accomplish what mikey has.

Mikey Garcia P4P #1

Finally...

Some objectivity into the discussion.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Look at it this way. The WBC made him vacate his title. Why do you think that is? It's because he was unable to defend it due to injury. I look at P4P rankings the same way. You have to defend your spot in the P4P rankings. If you aren't actively fighting, for whatever reason, you shouldn't be on that list.

Explain to me why other active fighters who are putting together a fantastic year should lose a spot in the top ten because of an injured Thurman? How is that fair? You having an inactive Thurman on the list is like penalizing a fighter who is putting together a great 2018 year, but instead of him on the list, it's Thurman.

It doesn't make Thurman any less of a fighter. It's just that he's injured, so he's lost a step in the rankings. He can easily get his spot back.

I'm sure plenty of others agree with me.

I disagree.

I think Thurman has earned his spot on Mount Rushmore.

One Time is All Time.

Make some waves for the Apocalysp!!

[The D3vil]

Look at it this way. The WBC made him vacate his title. Why do you think that is? It's because he was unable to defend it due to injury. I look at P4P rankings the same way. You have to defend your spot in the P4P rankings. If you aren't actively fighting, for whatever reason, you shouldn't be on that list.

Explain to me why other active fighters who are putting together a fantastic year should lose a spot in the top ten because of an injured Thurman? How is that fair? You having an inactive Thurman on the list is like penalizing a fighter who is putting together a great 2018 year, but instead of him on the list, it's Thurman.

It doesn't make Thurman any less of a fighter. It's just that he's injured, so he's lost a step in the rankings. He can easily get his spot back.

I'm sure plenty of others agree with me.

THIS

And in all honesty, he was barely in the top 10 in 2017

[Jubei]

There are 3 absolute elite top 3 P4P fighters right now, and after that there are a couple contenders. Garcia is #6.

#1 Loma
#2 GGG
#3 Usyk
_______________

#4 Crawford
#5 Inoue
#6 Garcia

[Sable&Whitefish]

1. Crawford
2. Loma
3. Sor Rungvisai
4. Golovkin
5. Wilder
6. Joshua
7. Thurman/Spence
8. Garcia
9. Groves
10. Canelo

I mean no disrespect, but can I ask you why Crawford deserves to be no. 1? It's not a challenge I'm just uninformed, I guess. I saw his fight against Gamboa and was very impressed, and some early fights he totally dominated against low-level guys, and his fight with Horn, which was good although I never expected it to go any other way and didn't see it as a huge challenge. What's the reasoning?

[KillaMane26]

Prolly 4 not higher than 3

[b Murphington]

I disagree.

I think Thurman has earned his spot on Mount Rushmore.

One Time is All Time.

Make some waves for the Apocalysp!!

Lol. But he hasn't done anything in 16 months, regardless of the reason! You can probably name at least 10 fighters who have had a great run in the past 16 months.

[LetOutTheCage]

I would have him 4th behind Crawford, Loma and Usyk and ahead of GGG and Sor Rungiavisi.

I think some will put him ahead of Loma because he beat Salido and Loma didn't.

Totally agree with this