Charlo gets praised for fighting bums, Gilberto Ramirez gets butchered for it

[Fidel456]

So what are we arguing here man?

The argument is the title of the thread

[Mammoth]

Ur missing the point. I'm not even saying Ramirez is better. I'm saying they both fight trash but one gets praised for it

Neither should get praised for their level of opposition. I think Charlo has earned praise by passing the eye test in major ways.

[Larry the boss]

Ur missing the point. I'm not even saying Ramirez is better. I'm saying they both fight trash but one gets praised for it

I dont see praise at all to be honest, seems like you are trying to make up an argument

[Mammoth]

Trout stop being good years ago. His the new PBC Robert Guerrero.

Trout stayed a cut below elite his whole career. Pretty much a gate keeper for the elites right now.

[Jubei]

Both beat up a bunch of bums and deserve no credit whatsoever.

The only reason Charlo is hyped up here is because he is black.

[Mammoth]

But Zurdo deserves credit for his Vlasov and Hart wins. Probably his Porky Medina win as well.

[Larry the boss]

Both beat up a bunch of bums and deserve no credit whatsoever.

The only reason Charlo is hyped up here is because he is black.

And this is where I leave this thread........Peace!!!

[Mammoth]

The only reason Charlo is hyped up here is because he is black.

Why do this?

[Fidel456]

Neither should get praised for their level of opposition. I think Charlo has earned praise by passing the eye test in major ways.

Ok that's fair. But u gotta look past that cause I been in the ring with some dudes that made me look like Willie pep but then turn around and get some heat put on me. That's y no fighter should b even mentioned in no p4p list until they're like in their 8th or 9th year of professional fighting.

[Mammoth]

Ok that's fair. But u gotta look past that cause I been in the ring with some dudes that made me look like Willie pep but then turn around and get some heat put on me. That's y no fighter should b even mentioned in no p4p list until they're like in their 8th or 9th year of professional fighting.

Nobody mentions either of these guys in P4P lists.....