Your middleweight rankings?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • N/A
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Jul 2017
    • 9269
    • 214
    • 0
    • 12

    #21
    #1 - Gennady Golovkin
    #2 - Billy Joe Saunders
    #3 - Saul Alvarez
    #4 - Jermall Charlo
    #5 - Daniel Jacobs
    #6 - Ryota Murata
    #7 - Sergiy Derevyanchenko
    #8 - Demetrius Andrade
    #9 - David Lemieux
    #10- Martin Murray

    Comment

    • Irony123
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Oct 2015
      • 1207
      • 42
      • 42
      • 10,032

      #22
      GGG
      BJS
      Jacobs
      Canelo
      Charlo

      these are my top 5. Charlo and canelo make the list because of the eye test and not based on accomplishments. I guess canelos "draw" with golovkin also puts him as a top 5 middleweight at this time.

      Comment

      • animelive
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Dec 2015
        • 919
        • 26
        • 13
        • 8,359

        #23
        Originally posted by Santa_
        Uh, have you guys ever heard of the eye test? Boo-Boo pasts that with flying colors.

        Think Inoue and Errol Spence.
        Inoue and Spence are active and fight decent opponents. I have no complaints on those two but Andrade getting rated in a list with GGG and Canelo is laughable. Dude fights once a year against no names.

        Comment

        • KingHippo
          Undisputed Champion
          • Jun 2016
          • 3457
          • 168
          • 40
          • 38,705

          #24
          Originally posted by 4truth
          No but nice story, I guess.

          anyway...
          I've seen Saunder struggle with Eubank and Lee (I thought he lost to Lee even with that 10-7 round). I just don't rate Saunders him very highly, if you do fine. Without these guys fighting each other, we're just speculating at this point.
          Oh please, don't deflect my question. You asked what he had done to rank higher than 7 and now you're using the eye test all of the sudden. So typically casual.

          Keep imagining that you know anything about boxing if that makes you feel any better. But we all know you're just here for the show and pom-pom waving, you'll probably never be able to rate boxers, you don't have the hardware for it.

          Comment

          • WhatDisButtonDo
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jul 2017
            • 1006
            • 40
            • 20
            • 18,811

            #25
            [1 /Champ: GGG]

            2 ) Charlo(I honestly think he dog walks the other contenders, this isn't hyperbole, but his size,speed and power basically is a huge hurdle for anyone. Not to mention his chin.
            3.) Jacobs
            4.) Canelo
            5.) BJS

            Comment

            • BigZ44
              Undisputed Champion
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Mar 2015
              • 35537
              • 3,042
              • 1,201
              • 162,112

              #26
              Golovkin
              Canelo
              Jacobs
              Saunders
              Charlo
              Murata
              Derevyanchenko
              Sulecki
              N'Dam
              Andrade

              Comment

              • BO$$NELO
                Banned
                • May 2018
                • 209
                • 17
                • 0
                • 421

                #27
                Originally posted by Heavyhands420
                Having a drug cheat infront of golovkin is laughable. Consensus says GGG won. The rest of the list i can accept but the fact that your dead set on putting a proven #2 ahead of a proven #1 is where the line must be drawn. You sir are oblivious
                What? What drug cheat? Ca$hnelo lives in Mexico and tested positive for chemical in Mexican meat. He's not the first athlete to do so and he won't be the last. A victim of living in a country with less FDA standards. Hair follicle test PROVED it.

                You referring to the BO$$ as a drug cheat indicates you lap up TripleCUCK man-seed.

                BO$$NELO was #1 @ JMW and now #1 @ MW. And...now...TripleCUCK trying to price himself out.

                1. Ca$hnelo
                2. TripleCUCK

                Comment

                • techliam
                  Caneloweight Champion
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Apr 2012
                  • 5526
                  • 371
                  • 23
                  • 42,424

                  #28
                  Originally posted by daggum
                  hey he's had one fight there against an uknown. good enough!
                  A bit like Charlo then

                  Comment

                  • BO$$NELO
                    Banned
                    • May 2018
                    • 209
                    • 17
                    • 0
                    • 421

                    #29
                    Originally posted by WhatDisButtonDo
                    2 ) Charlo(I honestly think he dog walks the other contenders, this isn't hyperbole, but his size,speed and power basically is a huge hurdle for anyone. Not to mention his chin.
                    He's been tested by...noone.

                    You can't make him "great" if he hasn't fought anyone even "good". His best win was Julian Williams and the verdict isn't out on him yet. Although JWill has bounced back good so far which is good to see.

                    Jermall, on the other hand, arguably lost to Austin Trout. So his only "step-up" in competition did not make him look any better. No KO, outboxed, gassed. Work rate won him the decision, but one could argue it should've been a loss or draw.

                    Comment

                    • boliodogs
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • May 2008
                      • 33358
                      • 824
                      • 1,782
                      • 309,589

                      #30
                      Originally posted by BO$$NELO
                      Canelo
                      Gennady
                      BJS
                      Danny
                      Charlo
                      Sergey
                      Andrade
                      Murata

                      How anyone else could have anything else is unacceptable. Those are the rankings.
                      So if anybody dares to rank the top middleweights any differently than you rank them it's unacceptable? When did you become the boss of middleweight rankings, you arrogant jerk? GGG is the middleweight champion and Canelo is champion of nothing at the moment. Most viewers myself included thought GGG deserved to win his fight with Canelo. No way n hell would I rank Canelo above GGG and I could care less if you find that unacceptable. Saunders's best wins are points wins over guys GGG had already KOed. I think Jacobs and Jermall would both beat Saunders so I rank them higher than Saunders.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP