If Lomachenko retired tomorrow, would he be HOF-worthy?

[GGG Gloveking]

Absolutely not. For anyone disagreeing, please tell me his top 5 wins.

I disagree, and without naming his top 5 fights, think so for the simple fact that he won 3 division titles in about half the fights than the next closest competitor

[GhostofDempsey]

Yes, on amateur career and accomplishment alone. If Lazlo Papp belongs there then Loma does.

[BennyST]

I think so. He's reached P4P #1 by a couple of sources (BWAA, ESPN). He holds 3 world records (fastest to a title in 1, 2, and 3 weight classes). He's got good names on his resume (GRJ, Walters, Rigondeaux, Linares). All in 12 pro fights.

Moot point though. He's just getting started.

What do you mean fastest? As in least time or least fights? Jeff Fenech won his first two titles in less time, not sure about 3rd though (don’t think so from memory) and he only tied Muangsurins old record for amount of fights.

[Navalny20!8]

Probably Linares, Rigondeaux, Gary Russell Jr, Walters, Martinez/Soa

Some fighters have asteriks to their names, but overall it's a good top 5. Not yet great, but looking at recent inductees, the requirements to get inducted are apparently not that high.

What are Vitali Klitschko, Naseem Hamed, Joe Calzaghe or Arturo Gattis top 5 wins?

I agree that it is a good top 5, however, that should not get one into the HOF.

If it was up to me, none of the boxers that you listed would be inducted into the HOF.

It is disappointing that the standards just keep dropping.

[-Kev-]

IBHOF is weak, it's a joke. So yeah he can get in, there's literally no standards to get in.

[Pigeons]

What do you mean fastest? As in least time or least fights? Jeff Fenech won his first two titles in less time, not sure about 3rd though (don’t think so from memory) and he only tied Muangsurins old record for amount of fights.

Least amount of fights. Tied for 1st weight class, set for 2nd and 3rd weight class.

[just the facts]

Yes. Anyone saying no should just stop posting

So which win took Loma into HOF status?

[Hond]

Nah, not yet.

[nubianpiye]

Yes he would

[asgarth]

I agree that it is a good top 5, however, that should not get one into the HOF.

If it was up to me, none of the boxers that you listed would be inducted into the HOF.

It is disappointing that the standards just keep dropping.

Yeah same sentiments, a hall of fame should be reserved for the best fighters ever, but nowadays it's just really watered down.

but answering the TS question, with the current requirements to get into the HOF he probably already has done enough.