2005 Floyd Mayweather vs. 2018 Erroll Spence

[MurkaMan]

I think Floyd at 28 beats Spence but Spence would give him a run for his money. Spence doesn't fight like Judah, he's not much of a counter puncher and he's nowhere near as quick. He's definitely bigger and more imposing than Judah was but I think Floyd would have the hand speed advantage, foot speed advantage, and reflex advantage over Spence, as well as the ring iq at 28.

I dont care about him fighting like Judah. I just think Floyd is a skinny little man barely started fighting at that class. Spence would punch holes through Zab and Floyd both imo.

[Johnwoo8686]

I dont care about him fighting like Judah. I just think Floyd is a skinny little man barely started fighting at that class. Spence would punch holes through Zab and Floyd both imo.

Spence is way too hittable bro. He didn't even get as far as Floyd did in the amateurs. Floyd is skinny but he's tough. He's fought big punchers and hasn't even been dropped clearly. I think Floyd could pot shot and move and win a UD against Spence but it wouldn't be easy. Chris Van Heerden and Chris Algieri were able to land punches and go several rounds against Spence.

[Squ□redCircle34]

Floyd by decision, he would counter Spence to death who's only chances is to go to the body and use his size!

But there's a chance Spence would be willing to just walk thru anything Floyd offers

[Johnston]

Really don't see Spence landing anything meaningful. He's a big puncher but he isn't fast and his defense is poor. Floyd probably makes it look easy

[Metho_4u]

Anyone else wanna make fantasy matches hoping someone would beat Floyd? Lol

[Illmatic94]

We'll be better able to gauge this fantasy matchup when Spence clashes with Crawford.

[M Bison]

Mayweather would duck him so bad, why even compare any version of Floyd from any time?
The simple truth is Floyd doesn't like fighting guys who are doing what Errol Spence is doing, the only moment of time Floyd would dare step in the ring with a guy like that is if there are signs of Errol slowing down.

You can't expect a guy who ducked Amir Khan to actually step in the ring with Errol Spence that **** is just ****** af.

[MurkaMan]

Spence is way too hittable bro. He didn't even get as far as Floyd did in the amateurs. Floyd is skinny but he's tough. He's fought big punchers and hasn't even been dropped clearly. I think Floyd could pot shot and move and win a UD against Spence but it wouldn't be easy. Chris Van Heerden and Chris Algieri were able to land punches and go several rounds against Spence.

Spence gets hit all the time. Doesnt matter. Floyd was a 130lb fighter, skipping up weight for money fights. Grownup Floyd whitewashes him. But little bitty Floyd who had barely come to the weight class, would get ragdolled. Spence is a 154lber who can make 147lbs. He is going to beat the living shiet out of Floyd and Zab both.

[Bad_Guy]

Floyd would light up Spence, who would probably not be able to touch Floyd in his prime. Too much of a speed advantage.

[elfag]

No comparison between both 28 year olds. Spence's best win is Kell Brook with his second best win being what, Chris Algeri or lamont pederson.

Floyd was a 4 division champion at the same age and lineal in several of those titles.