Any boxing analysts / boxers give their opinion on fight?

[fabzmm]

I'm interested on what boxing analysts such as kellerman/atlas etc had to say about the fight and who won. Also any boxers give their opinions?

[Rockin']

It was a close fight. If Winky would have given more in the 12th it would have been his. I am comfortable with the decision of it being a draw.

Rockin'

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

If there EVER was a bout that needed to be a draw.. LAST NIGHT WAS IT.. Winky to me looked the better overall professional fighter but Jermain was always able to use his power, strength and youthfulness to stay right in the thick of things

[ferocity]

Winky did all he could do, Taylor still could have done more

[everlast99]

If there EVER was a bout that needed to be a draw.. LAST NIGHT WAS IT.. Winky to me looked the better overall professional fighter but Jermain was always able to use his power, strength and youthfulness to stay right in the thick of things

you damn right

[Kball15]

If there EVER was a bout that needed to be a draw.. LAST NIGHT WAS IT.. Winky to me looked the better overall professional fighter but Jermain was always able to use his power, strength and youthfulness to stay right in the thick of things

yea i agree also. Im a winky fan, so i should be running around these forumns sayin how winky won, just like the taylor fans are doing with their fighter.

But i honestly think it was an even draw. I had it a perfect draw on my scorecard, and i dont see how u could have it any worse then a 115-113 fight. i really dont

[Kball15]

o, and we'll see on wednesday night fights or FNFs to see Atlas's and Brian kennies opinion on the bout. im acutally looking forward to what he has to say. last time he talked about hatton, and got interupted by something. hopefully there will be no distractions this time

[Mr. Ryan]

I believe that a draw was a very reasonable decisions. It's very rare when two fighters fight at such a high level of talent. Both could make arguments given how effective they each were with their contrasting techniques. It was such a close fight, that anyone's thought on the winner would be purely opinion and impossible to verify or disprove. Here is the article I wrote recapping the fight:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=77864

[deliveryman]

yea i agree also. Im a winky fan, so i should be running around these forumns sayin how winky won, just like the taylor fans are doing with their fighter.

But i honestly think it was an even draw. I had it a perfect draw on my scorecard, and i dont see how u could have it any worse then a 115-113 fight. i really dont

I agree with that, I had it 115-114 Taylor, one of the rounds being even. 6-5-1

I'm not a fan of either fighter, but I just thought Taylor handed the harder more effective shots and hurt Winky more.