Who is the Pound 4 Pound best?

[deliveryman]

Whoa, relax buddy, I wouldn't want you to get an ulcer.

The keyword of that post, are you ready for it? Here it comes!!

you could be curteous

[Da Iceman]

mayweather jr.

[willjoes]

I would say...Camacho JR!! Just kidding. I would have to go with Joe Calzaghe. Iv only seen a few of his fights, but one of them was when he destroyed Left Hook Lacy. With that performance alone he won my vote.

I respect your opinion on joe but it is not fare to gage him based on his performance against soooooo green and sooooo one demesional and soooooo overated jeff lacy. he is however in the top three. winning that many fights without a loss is impressive

1. pbf
2.hopkins (he spit the fights the taylor)
3. calzaghe( until someone beats him he is in the same boat as hopkins was long title reign)

[Newportz]

rofl@ Calzaghe...

Are people kidding when they mention this guy? 1 decent win deserves no recognition...Lacy wasn't even tested...He was pure contender...


Mayweather is the best Pound-4-Pound fighter in the sport....

[Newportz]

I can't hate on europeans for wishing the best for Calzaghe...

I remember when I was stationed in Germany for 4 years, the germans were trying to tell me that Dariusz Michalczewski was the best Light Heavyweight...

and the Klitschko brothers were on every damn billboard in the country( this was before Vitali was even decent and before Dariusz had lost a fight)...

Rooting for your country is acceptable...It's patriotism in it's finest...

But Hatton and Calzaghe are not near the best P4P...let them prove themselves....I enjoy both of them, but reality has to play a part in your rankings....

[STC]

I would say...Camacho JR!! Just kidding. I would have to go with Joe Calzaghe. Iv only seen a few of his fights, but one of them was when he destroyed Left Hook Lacy. With that performance alone he won my vote.

1 fight makes him the best fighter in the world?

[ßringer]

That's bull****, we all know the pound for pound best fighter in the world is Donald Hoskins.....

[willjoes]

I can't hate on europeans for wishing the best for Calzaghe...

I remember when I was stationed in Germany for 4 years, the germans were trying to tell me that Dariusz Michalczewski was the best Light Heavyweight...

and the Klitschko brothers were on every damn billboard in the country( this was before Vitali was even decent and before Dariusz had lost a fight)...

Rooting for your country is acceptable...It's patriotism in it's finest...

But Hatton and Calzaghe are not near the best P4P...let them prove themselves....I enjoy both of them, but reality has to play a part in your rankings....

I am not european and I put calzaghe in the top 3. its hard not to when people still place M.A.B in the top 5 and that is funny. I agree with you about hatton. I dont think he belongs any place in the top 10 but joe is diffrent.His steak of title defences is enough to rate him high.

[DLT]

I am not european and I put calzaghe in the top 3. its hard not to when people still place M.A.B in the top 5 and that is funny. I agree with you about hatton. I dont think he belongs any place in the top 10 but joe is diffrent.His steak of title defences is enough to rate him high.

Anyone can have a streak if its not against elite talent. Hatton's resume is much better then Calzaghe. Joe is good but you guys are pretty much basing everything off of a win over a very green Lacy. Atleast Hatton beat a great fighter in Tszyu. You could argue that a win over Lacy isnt much different then Margarito bombing out Cintron