Where do u rate B-Hop p4p at the present ?

[realheavyhands]

But Tarver wasn't even rated in the top 10 and Jermain would also beat Bernard if they fought again.
I'd put him probably in the 8th slot

im sorry but jermaine didnt beat bernard jim lampley did

[shellroc513]

Mike R. I feel u man and appreciate the substance behind ur opinion. If jt wins against winky, ur right it does speak very highly of him, but I highly doubt he wins. Highly doubt it. I just think B-hop should be rated very hight if not number 1 because of his accomplishments and secondly I dont think jt beat him, but either way he is still disputed champ

[Mike_R]

yeah nah man i'm with you, and i wont be shocked if taylor beats winky but man... it's ****in winky- hah. i just don't see anything close to an easy win for taylor, if a win at all. i had winky picked to win for months but manny steward hopping into taylor's corner has really pushed this into the pick em' zone for me.

but for the sake of keeping the topic alive- bhop is top 10 p4p no matter what right now and hopefully he'll retire, because i don't foresee roy jones coming out looking to fight hopkins any time.

[paulmmv]

i think he could very well be right up there in the top 5 and thats amazing at 41 years old

[yrrej]

He made me a believer.

[enadeus]

Well he retired so he will not be in my list, but he is definetly top 10 at the moment if fictionally he was still active. This just shows you how good Jermaine Taylors wins over Hopkins really were, Hopkins win over Tarver that is, or it might just be that Tarver was never that good. Who knows?

[AintGottaClue]

well if he retired then he cant be on the list but he at least has to be 10, i mean i think he got robbed twice vs JT but after "losing" twice and going up 2 weight classes at 41 years young and DOMINATING the LTHW champ, he has to be at least 10

[DiegoFuego]

i agree with the fighters on ur P4P list, but the order.

My P4P Rankings:
1. Floyd Mayweather (147)
2. Manny Pacquiao (130)
3. Winky Wright (160)
4. Jermain Taylor (160)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera (130)
6. Bernard Hopkins (175)
7. Joe Calzaghe (168)
8. Rafael Marquez (122)
9. Ricky Hatton (147)
10. Diego Corrales (135)

why do you all have Hatton and Calzaghe below Barrera?

I'd go
1) Mayweather
2) Wright
3) Pacquiao
4) Taylor
5) Hatton
6) Calzaghe
7) Hopkins
8) Barrera
9) Corrales
10) Anybody who wants to fight for it I guess, lol. Freitas maybe? He only has 1 loss to Corrales and he beat Raheem, who beat Morales. I guess I'd go Freitas here.

[Mishra100]

I'm not sure why everyone counted out Hopkins after his 2 defeats with one fighter... This was my previous p4p list

"1. Floyd
2. Pac
3. Wright
4. Barrera
5. Hatton
6. Calzaghe
7. Tarver
8. Mosley
9. Toney
10. Castillo

Very close runners up (Wlad, Morales, Taylor, Hopkins, and I think that is it)"

I would say it is now

1. Floyd
2. Pac
3. Wright
4. Barrera
5. Calzaghe
6. Mosley
7. Hatton
8. Hopkins
9. Cotto
10. Toney


Very close runners up (Wlad, Morales, Taylor, Tarver)

[INFIGHT]

8 or 9.
He has one win in his last three fights.

Yeah but don't forget those two losses where close and controversial.