Paulie vs Antonio.. Who got it worse?

[King Jaffe Joffer]

They both got punished. But I think Paulie got a serious beating, but at the sametime won fans over. Paulie talked **** but I think it was to fill seats. Tarver talked **** and BELIEVED HIS ****. Those wins over a shot coward washed up Roy Jones got to his head something serious. I think Tarver has to be more embarressed than Paulie by a long shot. Mag actually put up a fight while taking his beating. Tarver just took a mild beating without putting up any fight.


LETS GOOOOOO

TAYLOR VS WINKY!!!!!!!!

[Piggu]

I'd say Tarver because I hate him. At least neither Winky or Taylor are *******s who talk trash.

[Shanus]

Malignaggi got physically the worst end of it, but in terms of a 'beating' it was Tarver, because he got beat with ease.

[MusclesMalone]

antonio got it way worse. paulie impressed the hell out of me. took a hard beating, and took it like man. he also made a heck of a fight of it, won 4 or 5 rounds. the same cannot be said for tarver.

[King Jaffe Joffer]

agreed........

[Easy-E]

The Paulie vs Cotto fight was actully close.
Tarver Hopkins wasnt.
Tarver took the beating.

[DiegoFuego]

Paulie won over lots of fans for his performance last night. Dude was cut 10 seconds in and covered in blood by a headbutt, knocked down by a left hook that broke his jaw, had his nose broken, and still won 4-5 rounds. Job well done for his first bout against a good opponent. Tarver should be ashamed of himself for last night. I think that loss to Hopkins will humble him more than anything.

[TyrantT316]

Tarver was beaten mentally so horribly...Paulie took some physical and mental beating...but not in a discouraging way...at least from an outsiders eyes...he proved that he could hang...

[psychopath]

It's not suprising that Paullie got the worse physical beating bewteen the two because his fight with Cotto was a physical give and take battle. But his losing effort still earned him respect.

Tarver on the other hand got the more humilation because he was unable to adjust to what Bhops has brought in front of him. He only got 2 rounds out of 12. That's a very one sided fight.