Who would you rank higher Cotto or Marquez?

[MrClutch85]

Too easy, Dinamita!!!

The Pacquiao KO will be spoke about forever while the Cotto Mosley win will be talked about here and there!

It's too bad neither guy ever fought each other, just like Mosley never got to fight Marquez

Miguel Cotto signature punch left hook to the body will be remembered in boxing history

[Luilun]

The Cotto knee ruined his legacy Marquez by far he knock Pacroid out Cotto once again took a knee

[BIG GUNZ]

Cotto's big wins?

Mosley (A fight that could have gone either way, refused a rematch)
Martinez (No legs)
Margarito (One eye and was coming on strong when the fight was stopped for swelling)
Clottey (A fight that could have gone either way)

Cotto's resume isn't so great.

JMM's wins over Pacquiao and Barrera are better than anything on Cotto's.

He also gave Malignaggi & Quintana their first losses. Marquez beat Pacquiao in their 4th fight under questionable circumstances. Marquez outside of his fights with Pacquiao, Bradley & Barrera has a very weak resume. They're pretty close though when thinking about it since to be fair some of Cotto's big wins were when they weren't in their prime really anymore.

[Bjl12]

Cotto fought better opponents throughout his career, but he lost every major fight.

JMM fought less major fights, but won most of them with only losses to Floyd, Bradley, and a draw in 2nd Pac fight (he clearly won fights 1 and 3). Couple of other losses although the alleged loss against that Thai fighter was rigged too

[Bjl12]

He also gave Malignaggi & Quintana their first losses. Marquez beat Pacquiao in their 4th fight under questionable circumstances

There's nothing questionable about a fighter being KTFO. That's actually as definitive as it gets.

The judges gifted immigrant poochmen fights 1 and 3...those were sad and questionable lmfao.

These pacFUCKS...lolz

[Bjl12]

Miguel Cotto signature punch left hook to the body will be remembered in boxing history

Ummm..by who? Lol

[BIG GUNZ]

There's nothing questionable about a fighter being KTFO. That's actually as definitive as it gets.

The judges gifted immigrant poochmen fights 1 and 3...those were sad and questionable lmfao.

These pacFUCKS...lolz

My friend who rarely watches boxing outside of one fight every few years even pointed out how he thought Marquez looked to be in incredible shape that night. He also mysteriously had a lot more power in the 4th fight than he had before. I think Pacquiao should have been given the decision in the 1st fight but Marquez should have probably gotten the 3rd fight.

[Elroy The Great]

much love for jmm. def 1st ballot HOFer, but cotto has the tougher resume.

imho

[iamboxing]

Like them both, but Marquez for me. Compare both their fights with Pacquio and it's obvious. Also, drug allegations unsubstantiated.

[b00g13man]

Marquez for me.