Skills Comparison - Wilder vs AJ (Objective fans ONLY)

[sotgoda]

Guys,

Not trying to start a thread just for the heck of it, but want a logical and objective comparison between the skills of these 2 guys. I have been asking to understand why the repeated statements of AJ being the better boxer. Thought it will be best to do a holistic comparison of what each guy brings to the table. I am certain I may have missed some aspects but here is my start. Objective and constructive (not delusional or problematic) fans ONLY. See below for my take:

Wilder:
Power: 9.5
Fighting on Front foot: 9.0
Fighting on Back foot: 8.5
Left Hand (Jab & Hook): 8.0
Right Hand: 9.5
Agility: 8.5
Head Movement (L/R, U/D, F/B): 7.5
Stamina: 9.0
Uppercut: 6.0
Footwork: 7.5
Defense: 7.0
Finishing Ability: 9.5
Experience/Opponents fought in era: 8.5
Intangibles (IQ,Balance,Fundamentals): 7.5
TOTAL: 115.5/140 (Rating: 82.5%)

AJ:
Power: 9.0
Fighting on Front foot: 9.5
Fighting on Back foot: 5.5
Left Hand (Jab & Hook): 7.0
Right Hand: 9.0
Agility: 7.5
Head Movement (L/R, U/D, F/B): 7.5
Stamina: 6.5
Uppercut: 9.0
Footwork: 8.0
Defense: 7.0
Finishing Ability: 9.5
Experience/Opponents fought in era: 8.0
Intangibles (IQ,Balance,Fundamentals): 8.5
TOTAL: 112/140. (Rating: 80%)

Thoughts?

[alexguiness]

my thoughts are...you need to see a psychiatrist.

[sotgoda]

my thoughts are...you need to see a psychiatrist.

Appreciate the feedback. You can exit to the next thread!

[HeadShots]

Joshua is text book. Wilder is off script.


Most importantly though, both are long range fighters. Wilder is longer, more mobile and more powerful.

[sotgoda]

Joshua is text book. Wilder is off script.


Most importantly though, both are long range fighters. Wilder is longer, more mobile and more powerful.

Appreciate the response, bro. What I am concerned about is this "better" boxer statement. Yes, AJ looks textbook, but like Wilder says, he will rather be the part than look the part. I think both guys are effective with their tools but using the word better bothers me, since I don't see it.

[FightLikeABroad]

Joshua beat and retires an ATG.

Wilder bigger name is Stiverne.

Next!

[Guest]

I find Joshua very "basic", and probably limited, but when either guys hit you, you know you're hit, so it doesn't matter in a lot of instances.

The Batty Windmiller has legs so far apart that his feet are in different timezones. But what he does works for him, so fair play.

I'd agree that BW appears to be the bigger one-punch artist, but when you're talking power at the levels of these guys, it scarcely matters.

AJ possibly has the better punch resistance, which isn't to say it's great? Wilder looks a bit fluffy around the chops IMO.

If either lands, it'll lead to the fight ending.

[sotgoda]

Joshua beat and retires an ATG.

Wilder bigger name is Stiverne.

Next!

Joshua beat an ATG coming off a loss, who was 41+ years old, and who was not a champion, and had shown signs of decline even in the Bryant Jennings fight. So, it is like Wilder beating Stiverne as well - although the latter is not an ATG.

That, however, is not a good side to side comparison of their skills. If you look at my rating, I gave AJ equal score in experience because of the Klitschko fight but that is not enough to beat Wilder imo, nor does it make AJ a better boxer.

[sotgoda]

I find Joshua very "basic", and probably limited, but when either guys hit you, you know you're hit, so it doesn't matter in a lot of instances.

Agreed, bro! Both guys definitely hit hard.

AJ possibly has the better punch resistance, which isn't to say it's great? Wilder looks a bit fluffy around the chops IMO.

If either lands, it'll lead to the fight ending.

AJ should have better punch resistance because he is heavier, but would that really matter if he gets hit? As Floyd says, boxing is a game of hitting and not getting hit. Right?

[Guest]

Agreed, bro! Both guys definitely hit hard.



AJ should have better punch resistance because he is heavier, but would that really matter if he gets hit? As Floyd says, boxing is a game of hitting and not getting hit. Right?

If BW lands on Joshua clean, he'll be in trouble, for sure.

Though I'm still not 100% sold on Wilder's power.... that fight with Malik looked dodgy as Hell.