Who is the Worst Boxing Judge?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • D4thincarnation
    Undisputed Champion
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Jan 2011
    • 16198
    • 533
    • 260
    • 133,240

    #1

    Who is the Worst Boxing Judge?

    Adalaide Byrd
    or
    C.J. Ross


    Or is there another that deserves this infamous title.


    Judge Judy could do a better job.
    14
    Adalaide Byrd
    42.86%
    6
    C.J. Ross
    50.00%
    7
    Other
    7.14%
    1
  • John Locke
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Sep 2013
    • 7818
    • 411
    • 287
    • 40,060

    #2



    This is a tweet from last week, how very predictable

    Comment

    • BrometheusBob.
      All Time Great
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Apr 2015
      • 20460
      • 916
      • 1,917
      • 156,555

      #3
      I still think CJ Ross' 114-114 was worse. I couldn't even find a round to give to Canelo in that fight. He really got tore up completely. No way was that fight competitive whatsoever.

      At least this was a bad scorecard in a competitive fight.

      Comment

      • D4thincarnation
        Undisputed Champion
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Jan 2011
        • 16198
        • 533
        • 260
        • 133,240

        #4
        Originally posted by John Locke



        This is a tweet from last week, how very predictable

        I think we were all expecting the judges to favor Canelo, that is how corrupt boxing is now, we expect it.

        But that prediction is crazy LOL.

        How did you have the fight mate?

        9-3 or 8-4 Golovkin for me

        Comment

        • John Locke
          Undisputed Champion
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Sep 2013
          • 7818
          • 411
          • 287
          • 40,060

          #5
          Originally posted by D4thincarnation
          I think we were all expecting the judges to favor Canelo, that is how corrupt boxing is now, we expect it.

          But that prediction is crazy LOL.

          How did you have the fight mate?

          9-3 or 8-4 Golovkin for me
          I had it 8-4, Golovkin's jab was landing all night. Canelo landed some good, eye-catching counters, but not enough, Golovkin was throwing and landing more punches and was the ring general for me.

          Comment

          • Brandon121
            Amateur
            Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
            • Sep 2017
            • 27
            • 11
            • 0
            • 6,113

            #6
            I still think Adalaide Byrd was the worst boxer judge.

            Comment

            • ////
              ////
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Sep 2014
              • 14948
              • 952
              • 671
              • 111,577

              #7
              lesser known lisa giampa is outrageously bad

              Comment

              • DuckAdonis
                Undisputed Champion
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Jul 2017
                • 7775
                • 197
                • 84
                • 188,446

                #8
                This should tell you enough. Fire her on the spot rn

                2014
                Vasyl Lomachenko vs. Gary Russell Jr. for the WBO Featherweight Title - Giampa was the only judge who did not score the bout in favor of Lomachenko. She instead had it a draw. Scores: Pat Russell 116-112, Lisa Giampa 114-114, Max DeLuca 116-112.
                2013
                Ik Yang vs. Hero Tito - Giampa was the only judge who did not have Yang winning. She instead scored the bout a draw. Scores: Lisa Giampa 57-57, Michael Pernick 59-55, Sawaeng Thaweekoon 60-54,
                Luis Arias vs. DonYil Livingston - Giampa was the only who did not score the bout for Arias. She instead had it as a draw. Scores: Robert Bennett 58-56, Lisa Giampa 57-57, Al Lefkowitz 58-55
                Marcus Willis vs. James De la Rosa - Giampa was the only judge to not score in favor Willis. She instead had the bout a draw. Robert Bennett 78-74, Lisa Giampa 76-76, Dave Moretti 77-75.
                2012
                Roman Martinez vs. Miguel Beltran Jr for the WBO Super Featherweight Title - Giampa was the only judge who did not score the bout for Martinez, instead having it heavily in favor of Beltran. Scores: Clark Sammartino 114-113, Duane Ford 114-113, Lisa Giampa 111-116.
                2011
                Joel Casamayor vs. Manuel Leyva - Giampa was the only judge to score the bout in favor of Leyva, who lost via split decision. Scores: Patricia Morse Jarman 97-92, Richard Houck 96-93, Lisa Giampa 94-95.
                Mickey Bey Jr. vs. Jose Hernandez - Giampa was the only judge who did not score the bout a draw. Instead she had Hernandez winning by two rounds. Scores: C.J. Ross 76-76, Glenn Trowbridge 76-76, Lisa Giampa 74-78.
                2010
                Raul Martinez vs. Rodrigo Guerrero (1st meeting) - Giampa was the only judge not to score the bout for Martinez. Instead she had it heavily in favor of Guerrero. Scores: David Hudson 115-113, David Sutherland 115-113, Lisa Giampa 111-117.
                2009
                Lonnie Smith vs. Khadaphi Proctor - Giampa was the only judge to score the bout for Proctor. Scores: Dave Moretti 58-56, Glenn Trowbridge 58-56, Lisa Giampa 56-58.
                Kourtney Boden vs. Clarence Tillman - Giampa was the only judge to not score the bout in favor of of Boden, instead seeing the bout a draw. Scores: Adalaide Byrd 39-37, Richard Houck 39-37, Lisa Giampa 38-38.
                David Springer vs. Rodrigo Romero - Giampa was the only judge to not score the bout in favor of David Springer. Instead, she scored every round for Romero. Scores: Dave Moretti 39-37, C.J. Ross 39-37, Lisa Giampa 36-40.
                2008
                Ty Barnett vs. Johnnie Edwards - Giampa was the only judge not to score in favor of Barnett, instead seeing the bout a draw. Scores: Al Lefkowitz 59-54, C.J. Ross 59-55, Lisa Giampa 57-57.
                Daud Cino Yordan vs. Antonio Meza - Giampa was the only judge not to score in favor of Yordan, instead seeing the bout a draw. Scores: Duane Ford 78-74, Jerry Roth 78-74, Lisa Giampa 76-76.
                Joe Calabria vs. Simon Ruvalcaba - Giampa was the only judge to score the bout in favor of Calabria, who lost via split decision. Scores: Lisa Giampa 39-37, C.J. Ross 37-39, Jerry Roth 36-40.


                She co-judged with Byrd and Cj Ross at times and Cj Ross and Byrd always had the credible scores just like the other judge, while Giampa was way off Mark
                Last edited by DuckAdonis; 10-21-2017, 06:24 AM.

                Comment

                • SugarRayCurtain
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Apr 2010
                  • 1856
                  • 126
                  • 13
                  • 17,736

                  #9
                  CJ Ross left because she had no more credibility
                  That said Id say Harold Ledderman is the worst unofficial judge, he believes punches thrown are more important than punches actually landed

                  Comment

                  • TonyGe
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Dec 2016
                    • 11867
                    • 379
                    • 149
                    • 173,865

                    #10
                    I think he had the Mayweather PAC fight 117-111. I see your point. The scoring in that fight was a joke by everyone including the press.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP