No. It's ****** because there's no meaningful way of comparing fighters in substantially different weightclasses who will never fight each other or have opponents in common. The whole P4P concept is a pile of subjective slug faeces little better than a popularity contest.
Comments Thread For: Golovkin: Pound for Pound Not Serious, It's About Winning a War
Collapse
-
-
I dont give a **** about P4pound. I just like to see good fights against good competition. I actually like what GGG said. It is true. Just hope tghis fight gets really good quick and is close so we can see a coule of more between the two. P4P is just speculation and it also helps when you have alot of good fighters in your division (Welterweights).Comment
-
Even Abel is a good guy. He is a hard working honest trainer and always keeping it real.Comment
-
Gennady is coming to fight especially after waiting years for a fight of this magnitude. No way he comes in less than 100%. This is going to be a great fight. Being number one pound-for-pound is great but having great performances against A-class fighters backs it up. For example Pacquiao was number one pound-for-pound but look at the long list of great fighters he dismantled in his road to the top. That's why I don't hold people like Lomachenko high on the list because even though he's extremely talented he hasn't had great counterparts.Comment
-
This is very true. If you disagree then that must mean your favorite fighter is not on that list....lol....lomachenko & golovkin do not belong on the list of top 5 that's for sure unless golovkin beats nelo & Jacobs then I would put him in. If lomachenko has beat ten champions with only ten fights then I would put him in the list also.Comment
-
-
I agree with GGG! All the p4p talk is just a matter of opinion & opinions change day to day! You can never really know who's the best fighter in the world because there's so many in different divisions. There's nothing wrong with having a p4p list but it's only serious to those who cannot take someone disagreeing with them! P4P is really just you're imagination of what if! The main reason you see so many fighters from the 140 & 147 divisions is those divisions usually have heavy competition & those fighters can actually fight one another. I would love to see Ward fight Crawford, Thurman, Loma, etc. but it will never happen but it's ok to have a opinion of what if!Comment
-
And there is nothing obvious in P4P list, how do we know if Ward would beat a 6 ft 175 version of Rigondeaux or Lomachenko or Crawford or Garcia?
I just don't know about that and you don't.
I think Rigondeaux masters boxing better than Ward who got his ears boxed off by Kovalev in the first fight.Comment
-
I dont give a **** about P4pound. I just like to see good fights against good competition. I actually like what GGG said. It is true. Just hope tghis fight gets really good quick and is close so we can see a coule of more between the two. P4P is just speculation and it also helps when you have alot of good fighters in your division (Welterweights).
Another sht thing to talk about for boxing snobs.Comment
Comment