First time caller, long time listener.... (P4P discussion)

[SeekDaGreat]

Winner of Canelo, GGG is where on the the top 5 P4P.
Loser is where? Explain. "peeleft:

[_Maxi]

Those lists are garbage.

[Holystroke3]

Don't think it's a "winner is #__ p4p" fight

A win doesn't push either one past Ward.

A Golovkin win probably puts him #2, does a Canelo win push him past others to #2? Idk

For the loser, I think Golovkin takes a bigger hit from a loss than Canelo would. I think the loser falls to 8-10 unless it's a great, close fight

Ultimately you really can't decide these things beforehand. Sometimes the performance means as much as the result

[SeekDaGreat]

Those lists are garbage.

Okay...... Why....?

[SeekDaGreat]

Don't think it's a "winner is #__ p4p" fight

A win doesn't push either one past Ward.

A Golovkin win probably puts him #2, does a Canelo win push him past others to #2? Idk

For the loser, I think Golovkin takes a bigger hit from a loss than Canelo would. I think the loser falls to 8-10 unless it's a great, close fight

Ultimately you really can't decide these things beforehand. Sometimes the performance means as much as the result

Fair enough. Let's simplify. Dominant perforneace either way. What happens to the P4P list...?

[Chuckguy]

Winner is P4P #5 loser is out of the top 10

[vaynardevil]

the winner will elevate his rank to 2 p4p
ward is still 1st

[SeekDaGreat]

Winner is P4P #5 loser is out of the top 10

Nice. Who exactly is the winner behind? I can personally think of maybe 3 and that's a stretch. Ward, Crawford, and I guess Loma? So winner, at worst is #4 imo. That's worst case scenario.

How do you you see it?

[Chuckguy]

Nice. Who exactly is the winner behind? I can personally think of maybe 3 and that's a stretch. Ward, Crawford, and I guess Loma? So winner, at worst is #4 imo. That's worst case scenario.

How do you you see it?

I have chocolatito at 4. He was robbed

[Holystroke3]

Fair enough. Let's simplify. Dominant perforneace either way. What happens to the P4P list...?

Dominant I would say gets either one a lot of #1 votes (more so Golovkin) but personally I'd say a dominate performance puts the winner at #2