Peak Marcos Maidana vs Peak Terence Crawford

[Mr Objecitivity]

The Marcos Maidana from the first Floyd Mayweather and the Adrien Broner fights vs Terence Crawford from the Gamboa and Viktor Postol fights.

Fight takes place at 140 pounds. Who wins?

[Dean_Razorback]

crawford would be favorite. but chino has a puncher's chance. especially if it's the maidana from garcia and ariza. could be similar to khan maidana maybe.

[Madison Boxing]

maidana stops him late.

[Ray Corso]

Crawford is by far the better talent, Marcos is a club styled fighter
who displayed guts and desire but he also got beat by Khan who can't break an egg and Alexander who couldn't break a broken egg!
Crawford lands shots from the southpaw stance that Marcos can't defend! I like Maidana and his first fight why Floyd was impressive because he made Mayweather run like a girl.

Crawford has to much of everything and Madiana's power is over rated. He threw nice awkward shots against Mayweather that worked well but will not work against a boxer that punches back.

Crawford by unn. decs.

Ray

[MasterPlan]

Crawford by shut out. 10-2 maybe.

[boliodogs]

I pick Maidana to win. I think he can survive Crawford's best punches but Crawford couldn't take his power. Crawford is a much better long range boxer than Maidana. Maidana would swarm him with his relentless attack and make sure much of the fight is fought at close range where he is stronger and better than Crawford. Gamboa hurt Crawford and Maidana is much bigger, stronger and a harder puncher than Gamboa. I think he wears Crawford down and stops him in the late rounds.

[MasterPlan]

I pick Maidana to win. I think he can survive Crawford's best punches but Crawford couldn't take his power. Crawford is a much better long range boxer than Maidana. Maidana would swarm him with his relentless attack and make sure much of the fight is fought at close range where he is stronger and better than Crawford. Gamboa hurt Crawford and Maidana is much bigger, stronger and a harder puncher than Gamboa. I think he wears Crawford down and stops him in the late rounds.

He couldn't even beat Khan or Devon Alexander. Beat Broner but couldn't stop him but stops Crawford.

[redmish]

Crawford by wide decision.

[Dean_Razorback]

He couldn't even beat Khan or Devon Alexander. Beat Broner but couldn't stop him but stops Crawford.

maidana's conditioning vs those guys was really poor. why can't people see how he changed with garcia and ariza?

[MasterPlan]

maidana's conditioning vs those guys was really poor. why can't people see how he changed with garcia and ariza?

Op says at 140. Those fights minus Broner were at 140.