Who do you rank higher Mayweather or Pacquiao

[Elroy The Great]

another one of these ?!?!?!?!?

[Larry the boss]

wow...........

[Thraxox]

that's not always how it works. hearns destroyed duran but duran ranks higher than him.

This is NSB, logic is allergy.

[Thraxox]

why do they have the same amount of lineal titles?

Manny is the Lineal champion of FIVE divisions, which has never been done before, Mayweather is Lineal of FOUR divisions, which has been done before. The First Lineal Flyweight that has become a Lineal Welterweight, never have been done before and would never be done again. The First seven and eight division world champion, never been done before and probably would never be done in the future. Pacquiao accomplished everything that Mayweather accomplished but Mayweather NEVER accomplished the accomplishments Pacquiao accomplished and that is a fact Larry.

Pacquiao has more historical significance than Mayweather by a mile and its not even close. In terms of head to head competition Pacquiao beats him, in terms of Accomplishments Pacquiao had beat him, the only thing that Mayweather has over Pacquiao was a win over him, and that was when Pacquiao was already an echo of what he once was.

Its easy to asses their careers. Pacquiao is greater than Mayweather.

[Larry the boss]

Manny is the Lineal champion of FIVE divisions, which has never been done before, Mayweather is Lineal of FOUR divisions, which has been done before. The First Lineal Flyweight that has become a Lineal Welterweight, never have been done before and would never be done again. The First seven and eight division world champion, never been done before and probably would never be done in the future. Pacquiao accomplished everything that Mayweather accomplished but Mayweather NEVER accomplished the accomplishments Pacquiao accomplished and that is a fact Larry.

Pacquiao has more historical significance than Mayweather by a mile and its not even close. In terms of head to head competition Pacquiao beats him, in terms of Accomplishments Pacquiao had beat him, the only thing that Mayweather has over Pacquiao was a win over him, and that was when Pacquiao was already an echo of what he once was.

Its easy to asses their careers. Pacquiao is greater than Mayweather.

Floyd is a 5 time lineal champion with just as many great wins as Manny BUT!!!He beat Manny aswell.. sure no fighter has ever won titles in 8 divisions..BUT NO FIGHTER HAS EVER GONE THROUGH 5 DIVISIONS WHILE REMAINING UNDEFEATED EITHER!!

[Thraxox]

Floyd is a 5 time lineal champion with just as many great wins as Manny BUT!!!He beat Manny aswell.. sure no fighter has ever won titles in 8 divisions..BUT NO FIGHTER HAS EVER GONE THROUGH 5 DIVISIONS WHILE REMAINING UNDEFEATED EITHER!!

5 LINEAL titles in 5 DIVISIONS Manny has in his resume. Floyd had only accomplished it in 4 divisions, thats one division above from Floyd Mayweather.
Resume wise Manny stomps Mayweather like a hooker. No prime A-level fighter in his resume. It's the head to competition that matter then the record. 8 Divisions/with 3 A-level Prime Fighters in his resume>5 divisions/undefeated/No A-level prime fighters in his resume.

Without the level of competition Manny has, Mayweather's resume look stale, thus us undefeated record doesn't look as great when the only "Prime" fighters he has are the Maidana's, the Guerrero's the Ortiz of the world.

Try harder larry.

[Elroy The Great]

add 30 no hopers (or if may fought as often as the haters wanted him to fight) and hes 79-0. if its ok for pac, it should be ok for may.

[gamesworn]

I have to give Mayweather the edge. Mayweather never lost a fight. Mayweather has never been knocked down. Mayweather beat Pacquiao.

Dude Zab Judah

[gamesworn]

I honestly think the head to head fight was the defining moment for both and showed us the superior fighter.

Mayweather is naturally bigger man than Pacquiao how could you use that as example.

Duran lost to Leonard 1-2, Hagler, Benitez, Hearns. Why was he ranked higher than all these guys? Think about it

[j.razor]

No even close....TBE