Mayweather Overrated?

[Easy-E]

i give him credit for zab. that's it., corley already got beat by zab. i love gatti, but he isnt elite. bruseles is a ****ing bum, and a walk in the park for anybody remotely decent at 140. if pbf doesn't fight hatton, margarito, oscar, or cotto in his next fight than he is just like roy trying to pad his record with the least risk. if he fights another bum than we all know what he is really made of.

you werent impressed by the way he defeated corley and more importantly, gatti?

[dansweeney]

you werent impressed by the way he defeated corley and more importantly, gatti?

the gatti win was very impressive, but oscar did the same thing ,and kayoed him. i just want to see him fight the best in the 147,140 divisions before he gets old like roy did. corley is a sneaky **** though, if he had a killer instinct he might have beat cotto, and possibly floyd.

[Easy-E]

the gatti win was very impressive, but oscar did the same thing ,and kayoed him. i just want to see him fight the best in the 147,140 divisions before he gets old like roy did. corley is a sneaky **** though, if he had a killer instinct he might have beat cotto, and possibly floyd.

but oscar was the bigger man in that situation, gatti was small and above his original weight.
i agree that i want him to fight dlh or hatton, but that doesnt mean hes not number 1 p4p.

[dansweeney]

but oscar was the bigger man in that situation, gatti was small and above his original weight.
i agree that i want him to fight dlh or hatton, but that doesnt mean hes not number 1 p4p.

hey, maybe i was too harsh, i agree he is p4p right now. but a p4p champ has to continue to prove that ****, im tired of everybody wanting to fight oscar cause he brings in all the money. i do think that oscar has the best chance to beat him though, because he is the bigger man, i think he can hurt pbf, but i don't think pbf can hurt oscar, especially at 147 and maybe junior middle. what u think?

[Easy-E]

hey, maybe i was too harsh, i agree he is p4p right now. but a p4p champ has to continue to prove that ****, im tired of everybody wanting to fight oscar cause he brings in all the money. i do think that oscar has the best chance to beat him though, because he is the bigger man, i think he can hurt pbf, but i don't think pbf can hurt oscar, especially at 147 and maybe junior middle. what u think?

oscar will be his toughest challenge. But i want to see him against Hatton.
I think floyd looks best at 140. hes got that speed and pop in his punches.
hopefully his hands dont betray him.

[dansweeney]

oscar will be his toughest challenge. But i want to see him against Hatton.
I think floyd looks best at 140. hes got that speed and pop in his punches.
hopefully his hands dont betray him.

after hattons performance saturday, he is obviously his best at 140 also, if that fight happens it should def be at 140. both men are at their best at that weight. on oscar, i feel he may be a little too big for floyd, just sheer size and power may prove too much for pbf in that fight.

[dansweeney]

he does have those hand probs. and that could cost him against hatton or oscar, he needs enough pop to keep them off him. but he does use the winning gloves now, so he should be ok with that.

[deuce_drop]

floyd is far from being overrated. he's just in a class of his own. each fight that is supposed to be his hardest test he passes in flying colors, with the Castillo fights excluded.

but each time he faces someone who is a ko puncher or someone who is going to rough him up, he out classes them and makes them all look like amatuers.

it's like roy jones jr when he was in his prime no one could touch him, no one could look good against him, no one could make a dent in him, it's the same with floyd.

it will come to an end, the only thing is can floyd retire before it does. he has the best chance of any fighter today to retire undefeated. i'd like to see hi do it.

[Easy-E]

he does have those hand probs. and that could cost him against hatton or oscar, he needs enough pop to keep them off him. but he does use the winning gloves now, so he should be ok with that.

true, but some of that pop is gone that he used to have. i can e****ially notice it with his straight right hands.

[dansweeney]

true, but some of that pop is gone that he used to have. i can e****ially notice it with his straight right hands.

look at hatton, 7 pounds can mean a big difference. cause a real welterweight has to come down in weight, hatton and pbf are true 140 pounders right now. neither one has the same power at full welter. at 140 pbf would have knocked out zab, but 147 he couldn't.