Which is the better win, Mayweather beating Pac or Pacquiao beating Barrera.

[Thraxox]

With guys like SemiGreat claiming that Barrera is already shot by the time he was 28 years old with wins of fighters like hamed, tapia and ayala. Who do you think gets this?

[Pechorin]

The fact that Pacman had already been knocked out and was not the same fighter afterwards ruined it. Also, the fight was terrible.

I say Pac's destruction over Barrera will be remembered over May's lackluster victory over Pacman.

[Elroy The Great]

everyone is too old, too slow, too young when they fight may

[JmH Reborn]

Jeez the Pac that May fought was just a shell - the Pac that was a monster faded in 2010

Why we still on this

[Reloaded]

Better is subjective, define better win ?

[Robbie Barrett]

Pacquiao was viewed as the 2nd best fighter on the planet at the time, only behind Mayweather himself. You can cry past prime all you want it doesn't change that it was a great win.

[Elroy The Great]

im a big mab fan but he was never a p4p king. nobody other than may (and jmm) was going to give pac problems. he can fight on into his 70's with opponents like horn and vargas.

[FinitoxDinamita]

Of course the Barrera win was better. That was a shocker at the time and that victory was what really put Pacquaio and Philipine boxing on the map....

Floyd over Pacman?? That was nothing. Outcome was expected.