I disagree strongly that Taylor is good for boxing
I'll go a step further. Until Jermain Taylor shows an ability to fight inside instead of just holding I think his success is bad for boxing, because it gives fans and other boxers the notion that if you have enough basic athletic ability you don't have to be a complete fighter.
I'm probably a rare exception to the general rule, but I root for boxers based primarily on their style, whether they're a credit to the fine art of boxing, whether they have all the skills and whether they show courage and heart, etc. I nearly always root against guys that clearly avoid infighting, which is to my way of thinking the style of the ultimate warrior in boxing. It's 1 thing to skillfully box on the outside and something totally different to also hold repeatedly on the inside. Take a good look at the way De La Hoya fought against Mayorga. He boxed on the outside but didn't clinch once when Mayorga moved inside on him. That style is in the great tradition of all the boxers who I admire such as Mike McCallum, Joe Louis and Alexis Arguello. Jermain Taylor isn't even close to that yet. He still has time to learn but honestly I'm not optimistic.
Originally posted by burglar
I'm probably a rare exception to the general rule, but I root for boxers based primarily on their style, whether they're a credit to the fine art of boxing, whether they have all the skills and whether they show courage and heart, etc. I nearly always root against guys that clearly avoid infighting, which is to my way of thinking the style of the ultimate warrior in boxing. It's 1 thing to skillfully box on the outside and something totally different to also hold repeatedly on the inside. Take a good look at the way De La Hoya fought against Mayorga. He boxed on the outside but didn't clinch once when Mayorga moved inside on him. That style is in the great tradition of all the boxers who I admire such as Mike McCallum, Joe Louis and Alexis Arguello. Jermain Taylor isn't even close to that yet. He still has time to learn but honestly I'm not optimistic.
Comment