How does Judah rank on the p4p list?

[PRboxingfan]

He doesn't rank. The guy has had 1 decent win and thatw as over a very vunerable champion in Spinks. Can you name me Zab Judah's second best win?...thats what I thought.

and no one on the planet who knows anything about boxing or is not taking money had Spinks top 5 p4p.

Exactly. His second best win would probably have to be Chop-Chop, but that's the extent of his wins against anyone B-level and above.

I considered Spinks a paper champion because, in my view, he lost to Mayorga and to Zab the first time around. Spinks was 15 on my list and I'd be happy to put Zab in that spot but not one position higher.

[bombshell]

i say nine... but if he gets a rematch with... kostya... and win... which i think he will.. he'll be rank higher...

i agree, rematch with kostya.
or a hell fight with dela hoya?

[Mr. Ryan]

First off, who the **** puts Spinks in Top 5? Spinks was a Top 20 fighter, but no 5. Judah I think needs 1 more big win before he gets into the top 10. He's got the skills and speed to beat anyone at 147, if he can stay focused like he was Saturday. I think he takes the rematch, TKO's Spinks again, and then I would like to see him take on the winner of Margarito-Cintron. If he can be the fighter he was Saturday every day, the sky is the limit for Judah.

[guru]

i cant see how off this performance anyone could pick zab over zoo... zab stil has one big weakness: a weak chin.... and sooner or later zoo will land on it....

[bombshell]

zab judah wins over spinks last saturday.
give him a credit......men!
but not too much..

[elveiel]

zab judah wins over spinks last saturday.
give him a credit......men!
but not too much..

I agree, i dont think you can rank top 10 P4P from one win.

Hopefuly we'll have good reason to rate Judah in the P4P's soon, even though he annoys the **** out of me i still respect his talents.