2008 welterweights vs 2016 weltwerweights

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Godsfly
    mental hospital toughness
    • Aug 2012
    • 4893
    • 369
    • 68
    • 22,498

    #1

    2008 welterweights vs 2016 weltwerweights

    who you got.

    clottey, williams, margarito, cotto.

    vs

    thurman, porter, spence, brook.

    first match......porter vs margarito. I say porter wins this. marg never in any point of his career knew how to deal with smothers. mosley smothered him & at certain points of the willams fight willams smothered his work rate. porter is stronger then marg (physical wise not power) and marg is slow. i see porter smothering him and getting off first quickly off the break.

    2nd fight: willams vs brook.
    competitive fight but willams ends up pulling a UD with sure work rate & out hustling brook.

    3rd match thurman vs cotto.
    hard hard match. i wanted to say cotto steam rolls thurman but not so fast. I certainly think thurman is much better then the zab cotto fought & both zab & thurman play the same outside game with the "stinger" thurman has 2 stingers instead of one unlike zabs one left. i also think thurman is on par if not better then the mosley cotto fought. but in the end I gave it A SD to cotto.

    4th match. clottey vs spence. I Gave this one to spence.....clottey was very good but could be out boxed & tricked. also something always weird happened to clottey when he stepped up. i think spence has enough power, angles, and timing to win A clear decision in this one.


    how would u score it?
  • Luilun
    Undisputed Champion
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Dec 2010
    • 12457
    • 555
    • 94
    • 58,436

    #2
    Originally posted by Godsfly
    who you got.

    clottey, williams, margarito, cotto.

    vs

    thurman, porter, spence, brook.

    first match......porter vs margarito. I say porter wins this. marg never in any point of his career knew how to deal with smothers. mosley smothered him & at certain points of the willams fight willams smothered his work rate. porter is stronger then marg (physical wise not power) and marg is slow. i see porter smothering him and getting off first quickly off the break.

    2nd fight: willams vs brook.
    competitive fight but willams ends up pulling a UD with sure work rate & out hustling brook.

    3rd match thurman vs cotto.
    hard hard match. i wanted to say cotto steam rolls thurman but not so fast. I certainly think thurman is much better then the zab cotto fought & both zab & thurman play the same outside game with the "stinger" thurman has 2 stingers instead of one unlike zabs one left. i also think thurman is on par if not better then the mosley cotto fought. but in the end I gave it A SD to cotto.

    4th match. clottey vs spence. I Gave this one to spence.....clottey was very good but could be out boxed & tricked. also something always weird happened to clottey when he stepped up. i think spence has enough power, angles, and timing to win A clear decision in this one.


    how would u score it?
    2008 by landslide

    Comment

    • baya
      Wrapidad was garbage
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Jul 2004
      • 14688
      • 807
      • 730
      • 31,790

      #3
      none of those cats can beat an 08 cotto or margarito, not even spence.

      Comment

      • The Big Dunn
        Banned
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Sep 2009
        • 69275
        • 9,488
        • 7,834
        • 287,568

        #4
        I would probably take 2008 because I think Williams and Cotto are the best and would find a way to beat all of the guys in 2016 even though I think clottey and Margs are the worst of this group an wouldn't beat anyone in 2016.

        Comment

        • Boxfan83
          The Coach
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Feb 2015
          • 15809
          • 2,066
          • 719
          • 160,371

          #5
          Originally posted by baya
          none of those cats can beat an 08 cotto or margarito, not even spence.
          Man its a shame how people automatically throw Cotto below these guys at 147 that havent fought anyone. I dont think people realize how good of a boxer Cotto was. Prime for prime out of all the guys mentioned, Cotto is on top with only Paul Williams in the argument with him. Margarito has to have a big asterik next to his name so I dont think he should even be mentioned. Besides I think the only one hed beat is Porter.

          Comment

          • Chrismart
            OK Jim...
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Apr 2007
            • 14258
            • 826
            • 1,757
            • 308,493

            #6
            2008

            Comment

            • baya
              Wrapidad was garbage
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Jul 2004
              • 14688
              • 807
              • 730
              • 31,790

              #7
              Originally posted by Boxfan83
              Man its a shame how people automatically throw Cotto below these guys at 147 that havent fought anyone. I dont think people realize how good of a boxer Cotto was. Prime for prime out of all the guys mentioned, Cotto is on top with only Paul Williams in the argument with him. Margarito has to have a big asterik next to his name so I dont think he should even be mentioned. Besides I think the only one hed beat is Porter.
              08 cotto squeaking out a decision against thurman, i 'unno man

              Comment

              • -MAKAVELLI-
                Banned
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Aug 2008
                • 50080
                • 3,580
                • 2,792
                • 169,000

                #8
                finally a good thread in NSB


                2016 dont want none of Paul Williams and his 1000 punches per fight

                Comment

                • bojangles1987
                  bo jungle
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 41118
                  • 1,326
                  • 357
                  • 63,028

                  #9
                  Margarito and Cotto probably whip everyone 2016 has. Not a guarantee, but much more likely than not. Hard to imagine most of 2016 dealing with Williams, either.

                  Comment

                  • -MAKAVELLI-
                    Banned
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Aug 2008
                    • 50080
                    • 3,580
                    • 2,792
                    • 169,000

                    #10
                    Danny Garcia vs Cotto in Puerto Rico



                    good times

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP