Mayweather will be considered #1 of alltime

[TopDawg]

Floyd just needs to beat Cotto and thats it. P4P Baby

He beats Cotto and retires as 40-0

100% correct.

[IMDAZED]

Leonard would have his way with Floyd.

And don't even mention Floyd in the same breath with Robinson.

Even if Floyd went out and beat a top dog in every division north he would still not beat as much talent as did Robinson.

I think we have a lot of Johnny Come Lately's on this site. It shows, man...such a shame. Guys gotta be 21 and below or just started following the sport with Floyd. I mean...seriously...

[Flab]

Leonard would have his way with Floyd.

And don't even mention Floyd in the same breath with Robinson.

Even if Floyd went out and beat a top dog in every division north he would still not beat as much talent as did Robinson.

Leonard is another overrated American, he was like the modern day Taylor.

[IMDAZED]

Leonard is another overrated American, he was like the modern day Taylor.

Yep, you're 20.

The day Floyd beats someone as good as Tommy Hearns, let me know.

[BrooklynBomber]

Bwuahahaha.

Kiddies are obviously out of their element here.

[Flab]

Yep, you're 20.

The day Floyd beats someone as good as Tommy Hearns, let me know.

Oscar de la Hoya, the 2nd greatest boxer ever.

[TheGreatA]

Leonard is another overrated American, he was like the modern day Taylor.

Don't ever compare Jermain Taylor to Sugar Ray Leonard again, please. Unless Taylor beats Pavlik, Kessler, Calzaghe and Dawson.

[IMDAZED]

Oscar de la Hoya, the 2nd greatest boxer ever.

[Jim Jeffries]

Beating Jake LaMotta and losing to bums makes you p4p#1?

Mayweather is already the best that ever lived in skill and record, beating Cotto would just make it more special.

You do realize SRR had more fights that Floyd has before he lost to a 16 lb heavier LaMotta, and didn't lost another fight until his 134th fight?

[Parody]

Yep, you're 20.

The day Floyd beats someone as good as Tommy Hearns, let me know.

I guess Iran Barkley was an alltime great as well.